Blake was introduced in Clare Crawley’s Bachelorette season and stuck around when Tayshia Adams took over as lead, though he ultimately struck out.
The third time was the charm on Katie Thurston’s season, and now the two are engaged.
ABC / GETTY
We saw Becca make it all the way to the final two in Chris Soules’ season and then attempt a comeback on Ben Higgins’ season. She was eliminated right before hometowns.
Becca’s The Bachelor season 19 castmate was sent home during week three. Amber then appeared on season 3 of Bachelor in Paradise and alongside Becca again on Higgins’ season.
Nick loves Bachelor Nation. He made it to the finale on Andi Dorfman’s and Kaitlyn Bristowe’s seasons, then appeared on Paradise season 3 and finally got his own Bachelor season.
Heather competed for Colton Underwood’s heart on season 23 only to come in sixth place. She tried to crash Matt James’ season, but he declined her attempt to join.
He made history as the first Bachelor to reject both final women in season 11, then surprised everyone by starring again in season 15, this time proposing to Emily Maynard.
Shawntel made it to hometowns on season 15, then crashed Ben Flajnik’s season in an attempt to join the cast. Ben sent her home after only one night.
You can’t say he didn’t try. Chris competed for Emily Maynard’s heart, appeared on Bachelor Pad, tried to join Andi Dorfman’s season and went on three seasons of Paradise.
Kacie left after hometowns on Ben Flajnik’s season — then returned to warn him about Courtney Robertson. She tried again on Sean Lowe’s season, only to be eliminated.