Willie Geist had to call the police after the comedian realized one of his cars was missing

Not everything went according to plan when Willie Geist conducted an at-home interview with Tracy Morgan.

While discussing his many celebrity interviews over the years on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on Wednesday, Geist recalled the time when he called the police at Morgan's request in the midst of their 2019 interview.

"After we talked, we walked around outside. He wanted to show me his automobile collection. And he said, 'Willie, did you know Lamborghini makes an SUV?' A family-friendly, sensible SUV, [for] taking the kids to soccer and things like that," the Sunday Today with Willie Geist host said. "So we come around the corner, Lambo's not there. We ask around [among] the members of the staff, 'Is it at the car wash?' 'Is it getting detailed?' 'Does my wife have it?' Nobody could find it. He looks me in the eye and goes, 'Willie, call the cops. Somebody stole my Lambo.'"

Geist continued, "So I'm at Tracy Morgan's house, doing an interview with cameras around, and his Lambo's been stolen. So we call the police. I'm the guy, having just met him, waving the cops down in the street."

Upon arriving at the scene, the cops were confused as to whether Geist was the homeowner. 

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

"I look up at the palace and said, 'Oh this? No, no, no. I'm just here interviewing Tracy.' And they tracked it down and it turns out, his Lambo had, indeed, been stolen," he said. "So it was an eventful day with Tracy." 

Credit: Mike Smith/NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty

During the aired version of the 2019 interview, Geist described Morgan's massive residence as "palatial" and a "universe all its own." The sit-down portion took place in a room that is "very special" to the 30 Rock alum, who said that he based the space on Don Corleone's office from The Godfather.

Speaking to Stephen Colbert on Wednesday, Geist also reflected on the unique trophy case nestled in the room. 

"If you look closely in the trophy case there is an Emmy, an Oscar, and a Heisman trophy in Tracy Morgan's case," he said. "And I said, 'Tracy what's going on over there?' And he said, 'Willie, this is America. Money talks,' which I think means he bought someone's Heisman trophy from them? I'm not totally clear on that."