Entertainment TV Lauren Alaina and Scotty McCreery's 'American Idol' Finale Songs The finalists performed three songs each before the last night of voting began – vote for your favorite By People Staff Published on May 25, 2011 11:00 AM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 03 WHO WON ROUND 1? Michael Becker/FOX (2) Randy and Jennifer gave the first round to Scotty, though both said it was a very tight race. "I would have to give up the first round ... to Lauren only because she's prettier than you are," Steven Tyler told Scotty, who said, "I'll take that." 02 of 03 WHO WON ROUND 2? Michael Becker/FOX (2) Though Randy declared, "They're both in it to win it!" he gave a "slight edge" to Lauren for round two. Jennifer agreed. 03 of 03 WHO'S THE AMERICAN IDOL? Michael Becker/FOX (2) After three rounds of competition, Randy gave a "slight edge to Lauren Alaina," while Steven said, "Lauren gets it hands down." But it's not up to the judges – it's up to the voting public and, as Jennifer said, "It's a tight race. America has their job cut out for them."