[IMAGE “30509276” “” “std” ]Sometimes it’s more fun being a villain. Take it from Bentley Williams, Olivia Caridi and many more of the notorious former Bachelor and Bachelorette contestants. While they may not have ended up finding true love, they’ve definitely made a lasting impression on viewers – and maybe scored a spot on a spin-off show or two.
Plus, now that we’ve got your competitive juices flowing, head to PEOPLE Games for more ways to test your celebrity IQ.
The Bachelorette airs Mondays (8 p.m. ET) on ABC.