Ben Higgins will confront all the women he's dumped this season on The Bachelor: Women Tell All Monday

By Aurelie Corinthios
March 03, 2016 03:25 PM

It’s the moment we’ve all been waiting for – well, except for Ben Higgins, probably.

The Bachelor‘s Women Tell All airs Monday, and PEOPLE has an exclusive sneak peek at the explosive episode when Higgins will confront all of the women he’s eliminated this season.

And the teaser doesn’t disappoint: From 50 Shades of Crazy contestant Lace Morris to the twins, we’ve got everyone’s favorite contestants back in the same room, and the tension is off the charts.

“I was severely bullied,” a tearful Olivia Caridi – one of this season’s most controversial contestants – says, while Caila Quinn, who was dumped by Higgins on this week’s episode, accuses him of seeming “rehearsed.”

PEOPLE’s collector’s edition The Bachelor, with new interviews and updates on your favorite contestants, is on sale now in stores and online!

PEOPLE's Celebrating All 20 Seasons of The Bachelor collector's edition
The Image Bank/Getty

A frustrated Jubilee Sharpe, meanwhile, demands to know: “Do you even see me?!”

And Higgins isn’t the only one in the hot seat: There’s also some score-settling amongst the women themselves, like Jami Letain calling out Leah Block for throwing Lauren Bushnell under the bus (for her part, Leah claims she was “kind of ambushed.”)

As for the man of the hour himself? Well, Higgins isn’t quite sure what to make of it all, evidenced by the big sigh he lets out when host Chris Harrison asks him if he regrets “going that far” with one of the women.

Stay tuned! The Bachelor: Women Tell All airs Monday (8 p.m. ET) on ABC, followed by the season finale the following week.