Fans are calling for these exes to get back together

By Michele Corriston
Updated February 12, 2016 09:00 AM
Freeform/Eric McCandless

Is there hope for Haleb?

In a sneak peek at next week’s episode of Pretty Little Liars exclusive to PEOPLE, Hanna (Ashley Benson) and Caleb (Tyler Blackburn) discuss the new cyber bully in Rosewood who’s using emojis to blackmail the Liars into solving Charlotte’s (Vanessa Ray) murder.

Hanna bristles at Caleb referring to the bad guy as “A,” but he assures her they’re not regressing back to their high school ways.

“It’s not the same person, but they want the same thing,” he says. “They want to make you miserable. But this time, you are smarter and you’re stronger, and you know that you can beat this because you’ve done it before.”

The topic turns to beer, then Toby (Keegan Allen) – Caleb’s old bro and the ex-boyfriend of Spencer (Troian Bellisario), Hanna’s BFF who’s now dating Caleb, her high school sweetheart.

“Things have changed,” Caleb muses. “Personal dynamics are different.”

But it’s totally fine, because Hanna is engaged to Jordan (David Coussins), a wealthy hunk with a sexy Australian accent who was super understanding about her tampering with police evidence … right?

As Caleb grabs his wallet to pay for their drinks, Hanna touches his arm, and their chemistry is undeniable.

“No, no, no. It’s good,” she says, smiling. “Next time.”

We’re not certain Spaleb shippers even exist (What happened to the girl code?!), and Jordan is cool and all, but it’s time for these exes to get back together stat.

Pretty Little Liars airs Tuesday at 8 p.m. on Freeform.