The girls are still trapped in Charles' dollhouse

By Michele Corriston
Updated May 01, 2015 08:00 PM
Credit: Ron Tom/ABC Family

A is toying with the Liars like never before.

In the first teaser for season 6 of Pretty Little Liars, Aria (Lucy Hale), Spencer (Troian Bellisario), Hanna (Ashley Benson), Emily (Shay Mitchell) and Mona (Janel Parrish) are the Rosewood cyberbully’s living dolls, forced to play by his rules in the show’s creepiest game yet.

It looks like PLL will pick up right from where the finale left off: The girls are trapped in Charles DiLaurentis’ lair, and after they nearly escaped following the prom night from hell, he’s taking his revenge.

“The girls are going to be punished for their actions by A, and slowly we’ll start finding out more about what exactly happens to them,” Parrish told PEOPLE in March. “Everyone is going to have some serious scars when they leave the dollhouse.”

Though creator I. Marlene King wouldn’t confirm the fervent fan theory that Charles is Jason’s (Drew Van Acker) evil twin, aka Alison’s (Sasha Pieterse) secret brother, the promo seems to match clues she did disclose.

“Yes, that is very possible,” she told PEOPLE when asked whether we may have seen Charles before.

Judging by the trailer, Charles seems to be forcing the girls to relive the night Ali disappeared, from the infamous yellow top she’s spotted wearing in the woods to the pink streak in Aria’s hair (so 2009).

And let’s #FBF to season 2, when a shirtless Jason (or was it CHARLES?!) flirted with Aria by telling her, “I miss that pink hair.”

Get all the answers when PLL returns June 2 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC Family.