“The time has come for you to decide whether you want to stay married or get a divorce,” the experts tell the couples in PEOPLE’s exclusive first look at the new Married at First Sight trailer

There's no shortage of drama in store for the latter half of Married at First Sight's season 12. 

In PEOPLE's exclusive first look at the new midseason trailer for the Lifetime series, the five couples navigate the highs and lows of their relationships as they ultimately seek to decide whether they will stay together or get a divorce. 

"I never thought when this all began that someone like Vincent was what I needed," Briana, 28, says of husband Vincent, 27. "I love him, I love him, I love him."

"Regardless of what we've been through, I think you're a genuine person," Hayley, 28, then tells her husband, Jacob. "I also respect you for committing to this."

"I'm very hopeful that we can turn things around," Jacob, 38, tells the cameras. 

married at first sight
Briana and Vincent
| Credit: lifetime

The footage next turns to Chris, 27, and Paige, 25, as they are sitting down to enjoy a meal together. "I pray that we can just enjoy one another's company tonight," Paige says as Chris later adds of his wife, "She's an amazing woman — I love Paige." 

The mood of the new trailer goes south, however, as Clara, 27, prompts husband Ryan to speed things up when it comes to saying "I love you." 

"What is the soonest y'all have said the L word to someone?" Ryan, 29, asks while on a double date with fellow couple Virginia and Erik. 

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

After Ryan reveals that he's "never said it," Clara replies, "If you haven't dropped that by six months, I'm probably leaving." 

Meanwhile, Erik, 34, and Virginia, 26, clearly have their own issues to resolve. 

"I want to get the f--- out of here," a frustrated Erik tells his wife while they're in a car together. "Then get the f--- out of here," she says.

married at first sight
Credit: lifetime

Despite Chris declaring his love for Paige earlier in the trailer, they also hit a rough patch. 

"I'm trying to have a conversation and you have nothing to say," Paige tells Chris, who responds, "I want to be in a serious relationship." 

"So do I," she says. "Why do you think I signed up for this?" 

In the end, the three experts — Dr. Pepper Schwartz, Pastor Calvin Roberson and Dr. Viviana Coles — tell the couples, "The time has come for you to decide whether you want to stay married or get a divorce." 

"I'm sorry y'all," Paige says as she begins to cry. "This is too much." 

Married at First Sight airs Wednesdays (8 p.m. ET) on Lifetime.