"He's not the typical look that I normally date," the newlywed says in an exclusive clip shared with PEOPLE
Credit: FYI

Will this be a case of Jamie and Doug or Jaclyn and Ryan?

On Tuesday night’s episode of Married at First Sight – the show in which complete strangers meet for the first time as they walk down the aisle – newlywed Ashley Doherty is just not that into her new husband David Norton.

“He’s not the typical look that I normally date. The men that I date usually have dark hair, usually dark features,” says Doherty in an exclusive sneak peek shared with PEOPLE. “Ideally there needs to be some sort of physical attraction.”

A very anxious Norton (who almost pops a cork into his bride’s eye) tells a standoffish Doherty about how nervous he was prior to the wedding day.

“I’m all in,” he reassures her as he plays with his wedding band.

To see how the rest of the couples click on their wedding day, tune into Married at First Sight (produced by Kinetic Content) Tuesday at 9 p.m. ET on FYI.