Toying with fans on Friday morning, the rapper reportedly posted – then quickly deleted – a photo of his ex to his Instagram account with the caption: “They always come back…”
In the image, which was screen-grabbed by eagle-eyed social media users, Jenner, 18, wore a tan, bodycon dress and long black wavy extensions – the same outfit that she had on in her own Instagram photos and Snapchats on Thursday evening.
Tyga, 26, however, wasn’t in any of Jenner’s posts from her night out, which included a trip to In-N-Out with friend Lauren.
The rumor-igniting photo comes just one day after Jenner’s rumored love interest PartyNextDoor, 22, released a music video featuring the reality star. In the clip for “Come and See Me,” Jenner and the rapper share a steamy make out session in the rain.
Related Video: Tyga Responds to Blac Chyna and Rob Kardashian’s Engagement
Earlier this week, a source told PEOPLE that while Tyga and Jenner are definitely broken up, “there is still so much love there.”
“He was her first true love and that is something that she just can’t walk away from entirely,” the insider advised of Jenner, who dated the rapper for well over a year.
“It was just bad timing and they were fighting all the time.”