Entertainment TV Katie Holmes Reunites with 'Dawson's Creek' Costars at Her Off-Broadway Show: 'We Love You' "As always ... you were a shiny star," wrote Mary-Margaret Humes after she and John Wesley Shipp saw Holmes in the off-Broadway show The Wanderers By Glenn Garner Glenn Garner Instagram Twitter Glenn Garner is a Writer/Reporter who works heavily with PEOPLE's Movies and TV verticals. Since graduating from Northern Arizona University with a dual major in journalism and photography, he got his professional start at OUT Magazine, The Advocate and Teen Vogue, and he's since consistently kept his finger on the pulse of the LGBTQ community. His first book The Guncle Guide was released in 2020 and was featured on Katie Couric's list of 100 recommended books of the year. People Editorial Guidelines Published on March 25, 2023 05:17 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Photo: Katie Holmes/Instagram Katie Holmes is never too far from the creek. The Dawson's Creek alum, 44, reunited with two costars from the beloved WB teen soap when John Wesley Shipp and Mary-Margaret Humes showed their support in the audience of her off-Broadway show The Wanderers on Friday. "Thank you @thereal_margaretmaryhumes and @johnwesleyshippjr for your support and love!" wrote Holmes on her Instagram Story with a photo of the trio and friend JC Alvarez. Katie Holmes/Instagram James Van Der Beek Says Dawson's Creek Mom Mary-Margaret Humes Sends Him Cookies Every Birthday "Always. Go see #TheWanderers" wrote Shipp, 68, on his story with the photo, as Humes, 68, seconded the recommendation: "So good!! As always ... you were a shiny star @katieholmes and we love you." The two played Mitch and Gail Leery, parents of the titular aspiring teen filmmaker Dawson (James Van Der Beek), who navigates love, sex and adolescence with his best friends Joey Potter (Holmes), Pacey Witter (Joshua Jackson) and Jen Lindley (Michelle Williams). Shipp previously enjoyed breakfast with Humes and his dog Sofia, whom he referred to as his "favorite gals" when he posted some selfies of the trio he shared earlier on Friday. The Stars of Dawson's Creek: Where Are They Now? "Early morning #nyc with @johnwesleyshippjr … what a wonderful way to wake up … coffee and #puppykisses #dawsonscreek 25 years later #foreverfriends," Humes wrote in the caption of her own post. Their onscreen son sent them love in the comments section. "Awww… all the feels ❤️ Makes me miss those weekend lunches we used to have," wrote Van Der Beek, 46. RELATED VIDEO: Dawson's Creek's Mary-Margaret Humes Teases 'Strong Possibility' of a Reboot Van Der Beek previously shared a video of his family opening up a gift from Humes for his birthday earlier this month, which has become a tradition. Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. "Every year since my mother died, [Humes] makes me cookies and sends them to me on my birthday," he wrote. "I have the best TV momma on the planet." Dawson's Creek ran for six seasons on The WB from 1998 to 2003.