Justin Willman married Jillian Sipkins over the weekend

By Michele Corriston
Updated September 10, 2015 04:20 PM

Magician/comedian Justin Willman and wife, photographer Jillian Sipkins, captivated with Internet this week with their hilarious Drunk History parody of how they met.

Now, the newlyweds are sharing the video of their first dance after they tied the knot Sunday exclusively with PEOPLE – and of course, it’s got a dash of magic.

Watch the couple groove to R&B classic “I Put a Spell on You” above.

“We felt some pressure to perform at our wedding since Justin is a magician,” Sipkins tells PEOPLE. “I think people expected us to make doves appear at the ceremony or something equally as lame. Neither of us are dancers, so we took the ‘first dance’ opportunity to put on a show with the help of our choreographer friend, Sebastien Stella.”

The best part? The bride seems to cast a spell over her groom at the end when he levitates above the floor. Abracadabra!

RELATED VIDEO: Amy Purdy Weds Longtime Boyfriend Daniel Gale in ‘Outdoorsy’ Idaho Wedding

“Our big move at the end was accomplished with a mix of magic and a few thousand sit-ups,” Willman explains. “It was a lot more fun than we expected (the practice time actually gave us a few uninterrupted hours each day leading up to the wedding), and pulling it off for our guests made it worth all the prep. The fact that people are responding so positively to the videos is really a bonus at this point. The wedding day was perfect, and now we get to see that reflected back to us by a whole bunch of strangers. It’s pretty surreal.”