Rodgers has repeatedly denied the allegations
On Thursday night, almost three weeks after Rodgers, 27, and Fletcher, 25, went public with their engagement after the season finale aired, Farrar took to Instagram to slam Rodgers in a two-part post (which has now been taken down).
In her first post, Farrar shared a lengthy open letter about Rodgers, slamming the former professional football player for going on “one of the most popular reality shows on TV” and allegedly lying about their relationship.
“That’s when I wrote my first post about him. I was hoping that would be the first and the last, but then the show ends (Hey, you’re finally a winner!) and he starts calling me a liar,” she wrote. “With the power of a press tour, his lies reached our hometown and my family and friends are now constantly approached by mutual acquaintances. After weeks of this, I started wondering why I feel like I’m the one who should be silent when he was the one who jumped on a reality show hoping to catch fame as a last ditch attempt to make something of himself.”
Farrar went on to claim that since the show ended, Rodgers has “been busy trying to push out new headlines casting himself in the role of the victim.”
“In every interview, he’s talked about cheating rumors being ‘really harsh and very untrue’ and how ‘hurtful’ it’s been to talk about his family drama, completely ignoring the fact that the world was oblivious to these issues until he put it out there,” she wrote.
She continued: “You’re wondering why there isn’t a flood of positivity around your engagement? Maybe it’s because your recent fame is built on you tearing down people and rewriting the truth to fit your storyline.”
“I’m laying it all out there because I don’t want to do this again,” she added. “Unlike Jordan, I’m not desperate to stay in the spotlight.”
Farrar also fired shots at Rodgers in her caption to the post: “After our breakup, I was surprised to find out what a prolific liar and cheater #JordanRodgers was during our entire 3 1/2 year-relationship. But what has surprised me even more is how he has carelessly bashed and lied about me in public. I guess he thought I wouldn’t stand up for myself. #HeWasWrong.”
In a second post that has since been deleted and then reposted, Farrar shared a video slideshow which includes a receipt for a bouquet of flowers allegedly purchased by Rodgers for another woman, as well as screenshots of alleged texts between Farrar and Rodgers from the same time.
A message to be delivered with the flowers reads: “Happy Birthday To My Favorite Bella. Miss You. Can’t Wait To See That Beautiful Smile Again. From, Your Favorite Football Player Wanna Be Actor.”
Though Farrar didn’t name the woman she alleges Rodgers was involved with and sent flowers to, she claimed he met her while filming Pitch Perfect 2. The Barden Bellas are the female a cappella group featured in the Pitch Perfect franchise.
“The Original Rose: The receipt for a giant bouquet of roses Jordan bought for the girl he cheated on me with in Louisiana. (The first of many I would later find out about,)” Farrar captioned the slideshow. “He met her while shooting Pitch Perfect 2 (he was deep in the background pretending to be one of the Green Bay Packers – the closest he’s ever been to making an NFL team).”
“I’ve included screenshots of texts with dates to show we were a couple when he bought his favorite Bella some very special roses,” she added. “And also one of the many, many texts he sent after we broke up.”
“Jordan, you dragged our relationship into the spotlight, and then challenged my honesty and character,” Farrar continued. “If you weren’t ready to be truthful about your life then you shouldn’t have gone on a reality show. And if you don’t like having your integrity questioned, you shouldn’t have lied about someone who’s parents always taught her to stand up for herself.”
Farrar added a series of hashtags: “#FromYourFavoriteFootballPlayer(‘s brother) #ExpensiveBouquet #NowIKnowWhyYouNeverHelpedWithRent #NotHisFaultCutFromPracticeSquads #DrivingHisBrothersTruck
#GoodThingTheRingWasFree #NeilLane #TheBachelorette #FameGoalsAcheived #YourChoiceIfThisIsMyLastPost #IveGotLotsMoreProof #DontCoverMyPeepholeAgain.”
In his recent exclusive PEOPLE cover interview with his fiancée Fletcher, Rodgers said the rumors that plagued him throughout the season were “awful.”
“It hurts because judgment and integrity are things that you build and try to maintain over a lifetime, and it just takes one person [saying something] out of malice that makes news,” Rodgers told PEOPLE.
Rodgers, who played football professionally himself and whose older brother is Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers, said “everyone likes to categorize professional athletes.”
“For someone who plays quarterback, let alone has the name recognition, it’s something I’m always fighting every step of the way,” he continued. “My entire life and career has been an uphill battle. I lived in 13 houses growing up. We never owned a house; we didn’t have money. So when people say I’m entitled, that’s not at all true. It’s tough when people who don’t know me assume that they do.”
Still, Rodgers’ focus is on “just being myself,” he said. “I definitely wasn’t on the show for fame. My goal every step of the way was to be open and honest with JoJo and let myself fall in love.”
As for Fletcher, she’s doing her best to distance herself from the rumors as well.
“As far as what exes say, I have learned to take that with a grain of salt from personal experience,” she told reporters during a press call earlier this month. “Jordan has never given me a reason to not trust him.”