JoJo Fletcher Recalls Exchanging 'I Love You's' with Ben Higgins on The Bachelor: 'Dear Lordy'
On his season in 2016, Ben Higgins famously told both his finalists he loved them
Monday's episode of ABC's retrospective series The Bachelor: The Greatest Seasons — Ever! will look back on Higgins' season in 2016, which saw the business analyst get engaged to Lauren Bushnell moments after saying goodbye to his other finalist, JoJo Fletcher. The proposal came after Higgins famously exchanged "I love you's" with both women — a big no-no, and the first time it happened in the franchise's history. (But certainly not the last.)
In PEOPLE's exclusive sneak peek, the show takes viewers back to the moment Higgins professed his love for Fletcher during their Fantasy Suite date.
"When I think about the future, there's not a doubt in my mind that I would want to spend it with you," Fletcher says. "I do, I do love you. And that's weird that I just said that, because I've been so terrified about saying that."
When Higgins tells Fletcher he loves her, too, she can't hide her shocked expression. They kiss, but then, in a confessional, Higgins admits he's torn between the two women.
"I am in love with two women here — I just didn't realize how hard this was going to get," he says.
The clip then cuts to present day Chris Harrison, who welcomes Fletcher via video chat.
"One of the more memorable moments in Bachelor history: Ben tells two women he loves them," Harrison recalls. "And I will never forget the look on your face. You have a terrible poker face."
"Oh, dear lordy," Fletcher replies.
But all's well that ends well. Fletcher, 29, went on to headline her own season of The Bachelorette, where she met and fell in love with finalist Jordan Rodgers, 31. They recently celebrated their four-year engagement anniversary and were supposed to tie the knot on June 13, but the coronavirus pandemic forced them to push their wedding date back a year.
The Bachelor: The Greatest Seasons — Ever! airs Mondays (8 p.m. ET) on ABC.
- Naya Rivera's Sister Lives with Ryan Dorsey to Care for Josey: 'Nothing Romantic Is Going on'
- Love Island Finale: Cely and Johnny Reflect on Their 'Beautiful Love Story' in Sneak Peek
- Author Rachel Hollis on Writing Book About Navigating Hardship When Her 16-Year Marriage Ended
- Kelly Ripa's Quarantine Routine Has Husband Mark Consuelos Saying She Looks 'So Healthy'