The pair went one-on-one on Thursday's show

By K.c. Blumm
Updated June 12, 2015 01:50 AM
Credit: Randy Holmes/ABC

Adam Sandler may be known as the Waterboy but it was Jimmy Kimmel who got more than a mouthful of the wet stuff when the pair competed in a friendly game of Sink It or Swim on Thursday’s Game Night edition of Jimmy Kimmel Live!

Each star was perched over a large dunk tank, and the first one to sink a basket would get to drop the other into what Kimmel described as “very cold water.” “I have no idea why it has to be this cold,” he added.

Why Are Matthew McConaughey and Jimmy Kimmel Trying to Break the Internet?

Sandler, who explained earlier in the show why he was sporting a shiner, joked that he’d been dreaming of this moment since he was 9 years old.