Cohen wore a wig and took over Alexis Bledel's role in a scene from season 1
Credit: Warner Bros./Everett; Inset: Getty

Where Andy Cohen leads, Lauren Graham will follow.

Hot on the heels of the Gilmore Girls reunion at the ATX Television Festival, the Watch What Happens host got Graham, 48, to reenact a scene with him Wednesday night.

With a green screen turning the Bravo Clubhouse into the Gilmore kitchen, Cohen, 47, wore a wig and took over Alexis Bledel‘s role in a scene from season 1, episode 9, when Rory accidentally spent the night with Dean (Jared Padalecki), sending Lorelai (Graham) into a fast-talking rage.

RELATED VIDEO: Who Is Lauren Graham’s Favorite Parenthood Costar?

Graham also revealed which of Rory’s boyfriend’s she’d want to hook up with in real life, and her answer echoes our poll of the actors at ATX: Milo Ventimiglia‘s Jess.

“I’m a brunette person,” she explained.