The nominees were Penélope Cruz, Merritt Wever, Adina Porter, Letitia Wright, Sara Bareilles and Judith Light
“I hope you don’t mistake my fear for a lack of gratitude,” she nervously said as she clutched her Emmy trophy in one hand and struggled to open the piece of paper in the other.
“I came prepared and it’s bombing already,” Wever, 38, jokingly added. “I wanted to be a grown-up about this.”
The actress was lauded for her role in Netflix’s Western. She fended off competition from fellow nominees Penélope Cruz (The Assassination Of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story), Adina Porter (American Horror Story: Cult), Letitia Wright (Black Mirror), Sara Bareilles (Jesus Christ Superstar Live In Concert) and Judith Light (The Assassination Of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story).
Check out all of PEOPLE’s 2018 Emmys coverage here.
This marks Wever’s second win and third nomination. She took home the Emmy for outstanding supporting actress in a comedy series in 2013 for her work on Nurse Jackie, for which she also scored a nomination in 2012.
In 2013, Wever’s 11-word acceptance speech went viral for her. Neil Patrick Harris said that she had delivered the “best speech ever” after she gave hilariously short remarks: “Thanks so much. Thank you so much. I gotta go. Bye.”
RELATED VIDEO: The 2018 Emmy Nominations Have Been Announced! Which TV Shows and Stars Wowed the Industry?
Wever opened up to Deadline in June about playing Mary Agnes on Godless.
“In some ways, I wonder if there’s a version of Mary Agnes that is a lot tougher, I think, than I played her,” Wever said. “I sometimes wonder if I did her a disservice, or if there’s another version of her out there that was tougher. I think she’s complicated and full of contradictions, too. I think she’s not as tough as she wants to be or pretends to be on the surface.”