DWTS: WWE Star Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin Goes Home in Queen Night Elimination
Another one bites the dust.
Each of the nine couples rocked the ballroom with two routines choreographed to the group's iconic hits. The WWE star scored 32 out of 40 for his foxtrot to "Radio Ga Ga," which was critiqued for being too tense.
"The dance has got to be a little bit more natural," Len Goodman said, while Bruno Tonioli joked, "I blame the muscles, darling! You were a bit tight at the beginning — very muscular!"
Meanwhile, Siwa and Johnson delivered a disco-inspired tango to "Body Language," which earned 39 out of 40. "JoJo, that was a tempting, tantalizing tango!" Derek Hough gushed. "Yo, that was so avant-garde, experimental. I absolutely loved it!"
However, Goodman gave a harsh critique of the performance, saying, "You've got to open up more. It was too neat and precise. It was lacking in rhythm I wanted to see more rhythm. I wanted to see you coming out and showing me something special, and I didn't really see that."
The Talk co-host also earned an extra bonus point in the Viennese waltz relay round, bringing her final total for the night to 34.
"You are just so genuine when you perform. It's just so infectious to watch," said Hough. "There was so much footwork in there. You didn't miss a step! I was watching with laser focus, and you hit every single step. That was a very challenging routine, but you were on point!"
Giannulli also earned four bonus points in the foxtrot relay round, bringing her to the top of the night's leaderboard with a final total of 42.
"One thing is for sure, this basketball legend is now an accomplished dancer," Bruno Tonioli said. "This was a very tricky paso doble because it had a rock feel, which you did very, very well. You incorporated your own individual style very well without going too far."
The NBA athlete later earned two bonus points in the jive relay round, bringing his final total for the night to 34.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free weekly newsletter to get the biggest news of the week delivered to your inbox every Friday.
"When you started this show, there wasn't a lot of dancing happening," said Carrie Ann Inaba. "And what I see now is full-on beautiful lines! You are hitting every line beautifully. You are interpreting the music. Well done!"
"You did have a little slip tonight, but I am so proud of you for getting out there and dancing," said Inaba. "I know you're not feeling well tonight. You did an amazing job."
The Olympic gymnast returned to dance again in the Viennese waltz relay round. She earned an extra bonus point, bringing her final total for the night to 34.
"I knew that if I didn't come out here, I'd be very disappointed in myself," she said when host Tyra Banks asked how she was feeling.
"I think that was your best dance because there was an approachable and soft energy about you that was just so refreshing to see from you, Cody," said Hough.
The Peloton instructor also earned two bonus points in the jive relay round, bringing his final total for the night to 36.
"It had sophistication, it had elegance, it had style," Goodman said. "I thought it was an all-around polished performance."
The Office actress also earned two bonus points in the Viennese waltz relay round, bringing her final total for the night to 38.
RELATED VIDEO: Emma Slater Sees the Bright Side of Not Getting a Perfect Score with DWTS Partner Jimmie Allen
Dancing with the Stars airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.