Entertainment TV Dina Lohan Was 'Suspicious' of Online Boyfriend Before Breakup, Says Source Dina Lohan and her online boyfriend Jesse Nadler have split By Melody Chiu Melody Chiu Instagram Twitter Melody Chiu is a Senior Editor for PEOPLE. She has been with the brand since 2009, editing, writing and reporting across all entertainment verticals. She oversees PEOPLE's music and events coverage and has written cover stories on Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Melissa McCarthy, Blake Shelton and Sandra Oh. The Los Angeles native graduated from the University of Southern California and has appeared on Extra!, The Talk, Access Hollywood and Good Morning America. People Editorial Guidelines and Maria Pasquini Maria Pasquini Associate Editor, Human Interest - PEOPLE People Editorial Guidelines Published on April 14, 2019 01:49 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Dina Lohan had already gotten suspicious that her online boyfriend didn’t have the best intentions before they called it quits. On Saturday, her ex Jesse Nadler told TMZ that the pair, who had never met in real life, had finally set up a time to meet, but broke up before that could happen due to a fight. However, a source close to Lindsay Lohan‘s mother, 56, tells PEOPLE that “there was no meeting scheduled” as “Dina was already suspicious that he was media hungry and she is in talks about doing several new shows, including a dating show.” “This guy wants his 15 minutes of fame — he just proved her suspicions correct,” the source adds. Dina Lohan, Jesse Nadler. Astrid Stawiarz/Getty; Jesse Douglas Nadler/Instagram Catfish‘s Nev Schulman Found Dina Lohan’s Alleged Boyfriend — Who Insists He’s the ‘Real Deal’ News of Dina’s relationship first emerged during her time as a contestant on Celebrity Big Brother earlier this year. During one of the episodes, she revealed that she’s been talking to “a special someone” for five years, even though they’ve never actually met in real life — or even FaceTimed. The New York-based star went on to explain that she hadn’t met her long-term boyfriend yet because he was currently living San Fransisco, California, taking care of his mother and he doesn’t use FaceTime. “It’s personal,” she said. “He’s real. I swear, it’s crazy. But I’m going to marry him. It’s really, really true. I talk to his ma!” While Dina seemed confident that her relationship was real, her fellow houseguests thought the star was likely being catfished — and apparently so did Nev Schulman, host of MTV’s Catfish. In February, Schulman revealed the identity of the man who claimed to be Dina’s boyfriend: Jesse Nadler, a 53-year-old from Tiburon, California, according to The Blast. “UPDATE: found @dinalohan’s boyfriend…but his story is way bigger than I could have ever imagined,” Schulman tweeted. In a follow-up tweet, Schulman shared a photo of Nadler, writing: “CONFIRMED: Jesse Nadler is Dina Lohan’s boyfriend. Much much more coming soon…” At the time, Nadler himself had been tweeting about his supposed relationship with Dina, insisting that he’s wasn’t catfishing her. “I’ll be the judge of that…” Schulman replied. Nadler, who said he works in commercial real estate, went on to tell Page Six that he had never met Dina in person due to his mother’s failing health, which she also noted on Celebrity Big Brother.