'Bachelor in Paradise' 's Danielle Maltby 'Blindsided' Over Paul Calafiore, Cara Maria Hookup Rumors

Danielle Maltby has been dating Big Brother and Ex on the Beach star Paul Calafiore for several months

Danielle Maltby is going through a tough time.

The Bachelor in Paradise alum has been dating Big Brother and Ex on the Beach star Paul Calafiore for several months, with both reality stars happily documenting their relationship on social media.

Over the weekend, however, rumors began flying that Calafiore had hooked up with The Challenge star Cara Maria Sorbello after the two were spotted at a Challenge Throwdown for the Cause event honoring the late Diem Brown.

According to E! News, Sorbello posted a video on her Instagram story in which she could be heard saying “Nobody has to know” — and appeared to be holding hands with a male wearing the same pinky ring worn by Calafiore.

“UGH @CaraMariaMTV…DO YOU KNOW HE IS A SERIAL CHEATER!?” tweeted one fan. “Not only did he cheat on his current girl with you, but he also cheated on his Ex-Fiance WITH 5 DIFFERENT GIRLS!!! I thought you were all about women empowerment!?”

“I’m single yo,” replied Sorbello.

MTV's "The Challenge: Rivals II" Final Episode and Reunion Party - Arrivals
Mike Coppola/Getty

A rep for Maltby told E! News that the star was heartbroken over the news.

“Danielle was completely blindsided by this,” the rep said. “She is hurting tremendously and would appreciate privacy at this time.”

The hookup rumors also blindsided fans of The Challenge, considering how outraged Maria Sorbello was when her MTV costar Tony Raines cheated on his girlfriend during The Challenge: XXX.

On Tuesday, Raines tweeted about the news.

“@CaraMariaMTV I’m not sure what’s going on but you have my mentions blowing up…something about you and a guy named Paul?” he wrote.

“This is apPAULing,” Maria Sorbello quipped in response.

Maltby, 32, and Calafiore, 29, made their relationship Instagram official in January.

“We’re just unapologetically ourselves,” Maltby told E! News in February. “We just have a lot of fun together. We goof around, we laugh, we play. I’ve never found someone in my life that I’ve been able to just completely be my goofy, weird 100 percent self with.”

“She makes me the happiest person in the world,” added Calafiore.

Related Articles