'The Bachelor' : Courtney Shoves a Pacifier in Demi's Mouth During Heated 'Women Tell All' Fight

The women did not back down during an explosive Women Tell All special

If The Bachelor: Women Tell All special taught us anything, it’s that Chris Harrison makes a terrible referee.

The special opened with some truly epic squabbling between everyone on the stage. It became almost impossible to figure out who was saying what as they all battled to be heard.

Just when it seemed as if the entire episode would be a series of high-pitched noises that only Catherine’s dog could hear, Harrison got a handle on things, and we heard from Nicole, Oneyka, Demi, Courtney, Caelynn, Hannah B. and of course, Colton Underwood, himself.

Eric McCandless/ABC

Onyeka vs. Nicole

The big debate between these two seemed to be over the word “bully.” Nicole insisted that Onyeka bullied her in the house, but Onyeka (with the support of a few other women) says she did no such thing.

“It just hurts me because what I experienced truly was bullying,” Nicole said. “She called me a psycho, she called me emotionally unstable.”

When Onyeka began to speak over Nicole and gives her the dictionary definition of a bully, Nicole pointed to their current interaction as an example of what she means.

“You spread a blatant lie to Colton,” she said. “You belittle me. You make me feel ostracized from the group, and you felt joy from that.”

Some of the other women then accused Nicole of talking smack about everyone in the house (“You said [Onyeka] wasn’t pretty enough to get a rose from Colton”). While Nicole didn’t deny it, she still stood by her bullying claim.

Eric McCandless/ABC

“I know the truth because I experience it,” she said. “You truly hurt me.”

Safe to say, Onyeka isn’t sorry, and these two will never be friends.

Caelynn vs. Katie

Caelynn finally got her chance to confront Katie about the claim that she and Cassie were plotting who would become the next Bachelorette and that they weren’t ready for marriage.

“I was frustrated that Katie didn’t just name names,” Caelynn said. “She threw every single relationship under the bus and put every single relationship in question, and that sucked.”

Caelynn then claimed that the conversation about the Bachelorette took place during a bus ride from an airport. She said she and Cassie were only being supportive of each other, rather than being fake.

“Obviously Cassie and I are best friends, and we were worried about what was going to happen to our friendship is one of us were to be engaged at the end,” she explained. “I said, ‘Cassie if it’s me at the end of this, I pray that you’re the Bachelorette and you find your person.’ That’s what best friends do.”

Caelynn also claimed that she called Katie after she left the show and the two cleared the air then. However, Katie insisted that the conversation went differently.

(Katie also said Caelynn slid into Bachelor Nation playboy Dean Unglert‘s DMs, but that’s neither here no there, because honestly, who hasn’t).

Kirpa also confirmed Katie’s side of the story that Caelynn and Cassie were being “manipulative.”

Hannah vs. Caelynn

If you were hoping to get more information on the feud between the two pageant queens, you’re going to be super disappointed.

Both Caelynn and Hannah refused to go into details over their past and instead insisted there’s no longer any bad blood between them.

Yay for friendship, boo for lack of drama.

Demi vs. Courtney

If there was one reason Courtney returned for the Women Tell All special, it was to finally confront Demi. But if she thought she was going to put Demi in her place, she was sadly mistaken.

“You act like a child,” Courtney said. “All you did was constantly open your mouth about other people. Anytime I had an issue with you, I pulled you aside.”

Demi said she felt regularly attacked by Courtney throughout the season.

Eric McCandless/ABC

“You wanted me to basically tone down Demi, which I would never do for anyone,” she said. “It’s 2019 and all you still haven’t talked to Colton!”

Demi did apologize for calling Courtney the “cancer of the house,” saying she was rather “more like bed bugs. I forgot you were there and then you just kept annoying the s— out of me.”

When Harrison gave Courtney the chance to get the last word in, she stood up and shoved a pacifier in Demi’s mouth while calling her a “child” and “immature.”

“Security!” Demi yelled as she threw the pacifier back at Courtney’s head.

But don’t worry, you haven’t seen the last of Demi. After speaking to Harrison on stage about her relationship with her mom, he teased a possible appearance on Bachelor in Paradise (who didn’t see that coming?!).

“You were definitely a fun to spirit to have, and something tells me we’ll probably see you again somewhere,” he said.

Colton talks to Caelynn and Hannah B.

After Caelynn tearfully admitted she was blindsided by Colton sending her home after hometowns and that she’s still struggling to move on, the man himself took the stage to face the women he rejected.

“When did you know it wasn’t me? Because I felt it all the way until the end,” Caelynn asked.

He didn’t really give her a clear answer.

“I think just that rose ceremony was the hardest out of all of them. I think it’s no secret that our relationship was special,” he said. “The safety that we had in one other in opening up and sharing things with each other was something that I will obviously value and appreciate. Our breakup, I didn’t have anything to say because I felt terrible. I didn’t give you any closure and I don’t know if there’s anything I could say now that will.”

Eric McCandless/ABC

Alright then.

On the bright side, Hannah B. said she didn’t have any hard feelings for Colton even after he sent her home immediately after introducing her to his family.

“I didn’t understand why I got to get into that part of your life if you didn’t have those feelings for me,” she said “I don’t understand it and it made me mad, but I think you have every right to do this the way you feel was necessary.”

“I grew as a person,” she continued. “I’m cool with you, I hope you’re cool with me.”

Colton admitted that he could have “done things better” as the Bachelor and apologized to the group as a whole.

“I think you’re a good dude and have a great heart,” Hannah B said.

Oh, and no, he doesn’t reveal if he’s still a virgin or not.

Eric McCandless/ABC

The fence jump

Finally, the moment we’ve all be waiting for. Colton finally explained what pushed him to jump over an 8-foot fence following his emotional goodbye with Cassie.

“The hardest thing for me was not being loved back,” he said. “There was a level of frustration. it was confusing, it was hard.”

The Bachelor airs Mondays (8 p.m. ET) on ABC.

Related Articles