By Lanford Beard
Updated March 13, 2015 01:35 AM
Credit: Randy Holmes/ABC

It’s an age-old question: Team Britt or Team Kaitlyn?

Sean Penn has an answer: “It’s gonna have to be Kaitlyn.”

The Oscar winner, 54, revealed on Thursday’s Jimmy Kimmel Live that he is an unashamed Bachelor fan.

More than that, Penn and his love Charlize Theron have already vowed their allegiance to one contender during the controversial next season of The Bachelorette.

Over the course of the last season of Bachelor, Penn says he and Theron, 39, would “argue about whether or not we should fast[-forward].”

“I don’t really want to hear the conversations,” he told Kimmel, 47. “I want to know the decisions. Is he gonna decide on this one or this one? And I want to see somebody cry. And then see somebody get ecstatic – and then see them cry.”

Joked Kimmel, “You could be on the Penn Tell All special.”

Penn shot back, “I can’t believe they got Matthew McConaughey to be the Bachelor and call himself something different.”

Touché, Sean Penn. Touché.

Is the New Bachelorette Series Twist Sexist?