The couple return from their Fantasy Suite date in this exclusive sneak peek at Sunday's episode

By Aurelie Corinthios
Updated September 04, 2015 09:05 AM

So did she, or didn’t she?

In an exclusive sneak peek at Sunday’s episode of Bachelor in Paradise, Ashley I. and Jared return from their overnight date – and the rest of the cast is anxious to know whether or not Ashley I. has lost her virginity to the Ashton Kutcher look-alike.

In case you’re not caught up, the reality star – whose much talked-about virginity made quite a stir on Chris Soules‘ season of The Bachelor – explicitly asked for an overnight date with Jared on Monday’s episode. He accepted, and Ashley I. teased to the camera that “she might not be a virgin tomorrow.”

In the new clip, the pair returns from their Fantasy Suite date to find the rest of the BiP ladies in the pool.

After being asked how it went, Jared simply responds: “It was good.”

A very long, very awkward silence ensues, and one of the girls eventually presses them for more details by asking what they did on the date.

“We went to a five-star hotel,” says Jared while Ashley I. stands beside him, uncharacteristically quiet. “It was ridiculous, the room was awesome. It was nice just to relax and get some AC and talk.”

RELATED VIDEO: The Bachelor Dudes Discuss Whether Paradise the Right Place for Ashley I. to Lose Her Virginity

And with that, they saunter off, leaving the rest of the group looking quite perplexed – except for Carly, who feels strongly that the magic didn’t happen.

“I think Ashley I. is more of a virgin after the Fantasy Suite,” she says in an interview. “Is that possible?”

Tune in to find out what happens on the two-night Bachelor in Paradise finale on Sunday and Monday at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.