Bachelor Contestants from Different Seasons Who Found Each Other Off-Camera — and Fell in Love

They might have struck out on their own seasons, but your favorite contestants from Bachelor Nation never gave up on love. Find out who hit the love lotto within the Bachelor family  
By Diane J. Cho
January 25, 2019 04:25 PM

1 of 7

Jason Tartick and Kaitlyn Bristowe

Rodin Eckenroth/Getty; Walter McBride/Getty

The two began a romance in January 2019 following Bristowe’s split from ex-fiancé Shawn Booth in November 2018.

On a trip to surprise Tartick (who competed on Becca Kufrin's season), Bristowe announced the rumored couple’s official relationship status on Tartick’s Instagram story. Surprise — he’s “with his sweet girlfriend!” the former Bachelorette exclaimed.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 7

Jared Haibon and Ashley Iaconetti

David Livingston/Getty

It took three long and bumpy years, but Iaconetti and Haibon finally got their fairytale ending. The two met in 2015 when Iaconetti appeared on Chris Soules’ season and Haibon was about to start his journey on Kaitlyn Bristowe’s season. Iaconetti said it was “love at first sight” once the two went on Bachelor in Paradise, but he kept her in the friend zone. Eventually, they got together off camera, and the rest was history. They got engaged in June 2018.

3 of 7

Deanna Pappas and Stephen Stagliano

Axelle/Bauer/Griffin/Film-magic

This former Bachelorette may not have found love with her season’s winner Jesse Csincsak, but she did find love within Bachelor Nation. Pappas eventually met Stagliano — the twin brother of Michael Stagliano, who was on Jillian Harris’s season of The Bachelorette — and fell in love. They got married in 2011 and have two kids together.

Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

4 of 7

Ann Lueders and Jesse Csincsak

Getty

After winning DeAnna Pappas’ season and later calling off the wedding, Csincsak found love again after meeting Lueders, from Jason Mesnick’s season. The happy couple got married in 2010 and just welcomed their third baby.

Advertisement

5 of 7

Peyton Wright and Chris Lambton

David L Ryan/The Boston Globe/Getty

Wright and Lambton may not have found love on their respective seasons but the couple, who met through mutual Bachelor friends in 2010, fell for each other and eventually tied the knot in 2012. The two have one daughter and one son together and an HGTV show called Going Yard.

6 of 7

 Elizabeth Kitt and Ty Brown

Ty Brown/Instagram

Kitt competed on Jake Pavelka's Bachelor season, while Brown vied for Ali Fedotowsky's heart. The two met at a charity event in L.A. and got married in 2014, and after enduring a tough road to pregnancy, were overjoyed once they found out Kitt was pregnant. The couple welcomed their first child, Blakely Elizabeth Kitt Brown, in April of 2018.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

7 of 7

Juelia Kinney and Aaron Bass 

Juelia Kinney/Instagram

After splitting up with Bachelor alum JJ Lane once they stopped filming Marriage Boot Camp: Reality Stars, Kinney put it all behind her and decided she was ready for love once again. Now, she’s starting a new chapter as an engaged woman! Kinney is engaged to Aaron Bass, Evan Bass’s brother — yes, the same Evan who is married to Bachelor alum Carly Waddell.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next

By Diane J. Cho