January 30, 2016 02:00 PM

Whether it’s a one-on-one, a group date or a rose ceremony, the ladies vying for Ben Higgins‘ heart on The Bachelor are always dressed to the nines.

But it turns out the software salesman doesn’t care all that much for sparkly ball gowns and elaborate updos.

“I like when a woman is relaxed and comfortable, when she’s feeling comfortable,” Higgins, 27, told PEOPLE in Mexico City while shooting the current season of the ABC show. “I don’t want her to have to always feel like she has to put on a face for me. I just want her to feel like herself!”

PEOPLE’s collector’s edition The Bachelor, with new interviews and updates on your favorite contestants, is on sale now in stores and online!

And true to his words, the reality star’s celebrity crushes are two of the most effortlessly beautiful women in Hollywood: Jennifer Aniston and Blake Lively.

“I’ve always had a thing for Jennifer Aniston. She’s just kind of stayed beautiful as she’s aged,” says Higgins.

The Bachelor airs Mondays (8 p.m. ET) on ABC.

You May Like