"If you have a natural gift, you've got great taste and you're unique, you've got a shot," Simon Cowell tells PEOPLE

By Karen Mizoguchi
January 21, 2019 12:00 PM
Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage

From American Idol to the Got Talent franchise, Simon Cowell has seen every kind of performer.

But with the new spin-off show, AGT: The Champions, Cowell is sifting through former season winners and fan favorites to crown one act as the best of the world.

“How do you describe someone as a champion? The thought process was who wants to be on the show and compete again? And more importantly who could be better the second time around?” Cowell tells PEOPLE of why the idea of Champions was so appealing.

“It was jumping into the unknown. You don’t know what it’s going to like. I think what was good was that everyone had to up their game when they were competing with different people and surprise results,” he says.

RELATED: Shin Lim, Paul Potts and More Return to Compete in America’s Got Talent: The Champions

Competing against the best acts in the world also means the level of talent has elevated. And at times, the most memorable acts from past seasons get eliminated.

As for why he thinks acts, such as Darci Lynne Farmer and Britain’s Got Talent winner Ashleigh Butler, were unsuccessful on Champions, Cowell says, “Sometimes it’s the decisions people make I guess.”

The longtime judge adds, “Particularly with singers, you see them come back and they have better song choices. Or with comedians, they have better material. The difference is there are international artists, that’s the real world.”

RELATED VIDEO: How Life Has Changed at School for Darci Lynne Since Winning America’s Got Talent

While Cowell has been developing talents for more than a decade, he shares that his views on being a judge have changed since becoming a father to son Eric.

“Now Eric is older, he’s nearly 5. I can see the show through his eyes. It’s very interesting sometimes I can notice with the show when he switches on and off, so that’s a huge help,” Cowell says. “Because I have Eric now, I look at the younger contestants in a very different light, thinking, ‘Oh God what if that was him?’ “

RELATED: Simon Cowell Says Son Is the ‘Best Incentive’ to Motivate His Work: ‘Would Love’ for Him to Take Over

Eric Cowell
Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/FilmMagic

Cowell has been a part of reality competition shows with an increasing amount of generational audiences tuning in — and he reveals talent is ageless.

“The one thing we’ve always tried to do when I was working on American Idol as well, never patronize people. If you’re good, great. If you’re not good, just give it up,” he advises to future contestants.

“If you have a natural gift, you’ve got great taste and you’re unique, you’ve got a shot. I think people, fortunately, have trusted the brand. Comedians, magicians or whoever, they trust coming on the show because they’re not going to get ripped apart. It’s a good platform,” Cowell adds.

“What’s so interesting, I’ve been saying for the past three or four years, a lot of kids who years ago wanted to be a singer, now want to be a comedian, magician, dancer or acrobat. So in that way, it’s changed people’s aspirations about fame is all about and how talented you have to be and the time you have to put in.”

Simon Cowell with his dogs Squiddly and Diddly
Ian West/PA Images/Getty

If he and son Eric were to audition for Got Talent, the doting dad says it would not be singing.

“We’d either do a swinging balancing trick or try out and train our dogs who are the worst behaved dogs in the world,” he says. “Probably the latter and it would be a disaster but I would be happy to do that.”

AGT: The Champions airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on NBC.

Advertisement