Comedian Abby Elliot tells PEOPLE how the actress reacted after hearing her impression of her.

By Christina Dugan
August 01, 2016 03:40 PM

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery … right?

After comedian and actress Abby Elliott did a spot-on impression of Drew Barrymore, she received a surprising reaction.

Speaking with PEOPLE Now, the Odd Mom Out star opens up about what Barrymore, 41, had to say.

“I had done an impression of her on some talk show and she saw that and really liked it,” she says. “She was always a good sport about it.”

The former Saturday Night Live star says that Barrymore, who guest-stars in this season of Odd Mom Out, approached her on set and totally remembered the impressions she had done throughout the years.

In her classic Barrymore voice, Eliott said the actress told her, “Oh my God, I love them so muuuuch. That’s soooo amaaaazing.”

The comedian also opened up about her upcoming nuptials to fiancé Bill Kennedy.

“We’re at the two-month mark, so it’s all about the little details,” she says. “Like the holders for the place cards. I’m like, ‘Where do I get those? Where do I even start?’ But all the big things and details are squared away, so there will be a wedding.”

Odd Mom Out airs Mondays (10 p.m. ET) on Bravo.