You Voted! Best & Worst of the Oscars

From the weirdest dress to the guy who should take it all off: See what you loved – and hated – about the Academy Awards!

01 of 07

CRAZIEST-LOOKING DRESS: CHARLIZE THERON

CRAZIEST-LOOKING DRESS: CHARLIZE THERON
Frazer Harrison/Getty; Kevin Mazur/WireImage

Almost half of you voted pink dress to be the weirdest at the Academy Awards. “Looks like she has two purple cinnamon buns on her chest,” commenter Michele observed. Runner-up: Zoe Saldana’s ruffled Givenchy Haute Couture purple gown. Ouch!

02 of 07

MOST IN LOVE: SANDRA & JESSE

MOST IN LOVE: SANDRA & JESSE
Chris Carlson/AP

Best Actress and husband Jesse James were, hands-down, the loviest, cuddliest, schmoopiest couple at the awards, with a whopping 68% of readers picking the twosome as most in love. Runners-up: Best Actor Jeff Bridges and wife Susan Geston.

03 of 07

BETTER OFF SHIRTLESS: RYAN REYNOLDS

BETTER OFF SHIRTLESS: RYAN REYNOLDS
Ian West/PA Photos/Abaca

Sure, and both have six packs, but it was The Proposal star who 65 percent of you wanted to see flaunt it. As reader Sarah put it: “I really don’t think people would have a problem if Ryan just ripped off his shirt and went with only a bow tie!”

04 of 07

FANTASY OSCAR COUPLE: JAKE & RACHEL

FANTASY OSCAR COUPLE: JAKE & RACHEL
Michael Caulfield/Wireimage

While presenting the Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay, and appeared picture-perfect at each other’s side, earning nearly half (46%) of your votes for twosome you’d most like to see turn their Oscar match-up into a real-life coupling.

05 of 07

AWESOME ADDITION: NEIL PATRICK HARRIS

AWESOME ADDITION: NEIL PATRICK HARRIS
Kevin Winter/Getty

The How I Met Your Mother star opened the show with a surprise musical number – riddled with scathing jokes about Hollywood like, “Can’t think about Botox without you all” – and 68% of you raved about it. “I wish he was the host,” commenter Michael Elliot added.

06 of 07

TOO MUCH THIGH: MARIAH CAREY

TOO MUCH THIGH: MARIAH CAREY
Empics Entertainment/ABACA; Kevin Mazur/Wireimage

Holy slit! While both and showed that the thigh’s the limit with their Oscar gowns, 86% of you thought Carey’s Valentino Haute Couture was the unkindest cut, saying she showed far too much skin for Oscar.

07 of 07

MOST IN NEED OF A CUT: GEORGE CLOONEY

MOST IN NEED OF A CUT: GEORGE CLOONEY
Steve Granitz/Wireimage

He finally lost the beard, but 69% of PEOPLE.com readers thought should take the clippers to his hair as well. Still, his shaggy locks didn’t stop readers like Mags from gushing, “George looks hot as always.”

Related Articles