People.com Lifestyle Style Jennifer Aniston's Sexy Oscars Dress Was First Worn by Jennifer Lopez! Inside the Epic Fashion Faceoff This is the most exciting style showdown you'll see all year By Brittany Talarico Brittany Talarico Brittany Talarico is PEOPLE's Deputy Style Director, where she oversees the brand's digital Style and Beauty coverage. This includes running lead on the Met Gala, which is among PEOPLE.com's top-trafficked red carpet events every year, interviewing the industry's top influencers (including all the Kardashian-Jenners), and breaking A-list celeb news (a New Jersey shore native, it is no surprise that her favorite interview ever was with Bruce Springsteen). Brittany is a style contributor to People Every Day Podcast and has represented the brand on national TV programs including Good Morning America and The CW's two TV specials on the British Royals. She joined PEOPLE from Cosmopolitan in 2013, where she was an Associate Editor. People Editorial Guidelines Published on February 27, 2017 03:12 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Philip Rock/Anadolu Agency/Getty; Kevin Mazur/WireImage There was bound to be a fashion faceoff or two pop up on Oscars night. Between the awards ceremony and the after parties, there are barely enough dresses to go around, which means an outfit repeat is pretty much inevitable. But one star who we rarely see in a style showdown just happened to wear a dress that’s been worn before. That star is Jennifer Aniston and she took on the queen of skin-baring herself — the one-and-only Jennifer Lopez — in the most epic gown battle we’ve seen in a long time. (And we’re all breathing into paper bags.) Aniston’s glittering, high-slit Versace gown is actually the same plunging style Lopez wore last August while performing on stage with Marc Anthony at Radio City Music Hall in N.Y.C. Aniston piled on the bling with her look ($10.7 million in Lorraine Schwartz diamonds including 100-carat earrings!), while Lopez added nude fishnets and simple drop earrings to her Versace moment. RELATED PHOTOS: The Most Memorable Trends on the Oscars Red Carpet The only difference we can spot between the two gowns is the tiny sheer panel that’s been added to Aniston’s Versace version to make the neckline a bit more modest. Philip Rock/Anadolu Agency/Getty; Kevin Mazur/WireImage And while it’s basically impossible to choose, we still want to know your thoughts. Vote in the poll, and share any additional comments below! What do you think of the epic showdown? Sound off now! –reporting by Catherine Kast