Lifestyle Style Guess the 'Bachelorette' Couple From the Engagement Ring! See every couple's Neil Lane sparkler -- and test your knowledge of who proposed with what By Alex Apatoff Updated on September 20, 2022 10:15 AM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 28 The Ring Courtesy Neil Lane Couture The groom-to-be was "mesmerized" by the pear-shaped diamond he selected for his Bachelorette, jeweler Neil Lane told PEOPLE at the time. For his part, Lane selected a ring with vintage-feeling tapered baguettes with the bride-to-be in mind: "I went back in time because she's a classical beauty," he explained. 02 of 28 The Reveal Craig Sjodin/ABC Though Michelle Young said she was "very happy" with Nayte Olukoya after he got down on one knee in Punta Mita, Mexico, their bliss wasn't long-lived: Olukoya eventually dumped her over the phone after a fight. He told Nick Viall on The Viall Files that they'd been discussing a breakup since shortly after their televised engagement, and by the time he ended things, "It wasn't our first time having breakup conversations. It was probably our third time having a breakup conversation." 03 of 28 The Ring courtesy neil lane This 3-carat diamond has a unique hidden halo studded with 90 smaller diamonds, which jeweler Neil Lane said was a metaphor for their relationship: "A lot of it is on the surface at first, but there is so much more than meets the eye." 04 of 28 The Reveal Craig Sjodin/ABC Katie Thurston called Blake Moynes' proposal "the start of forever" before riding off into the sunset on horseback with him. She also felt the ring was as "meant to be" as the relationship: "It's simple and it's elegant — and not too flashy. When I saw it, I just realized, 'Wow, Blake knows me so well.'" The couple called it quits later that same year. 05 of 28 The Ring Courtesy Neil Lane This 4.5-carat Neil Lane-designed emerald-cut diamond flanked by two "shield-shaped" diamonds and a diamond-encrusted band was a "show-stopper" in the most literal way. 06 of 28 The Reveal Dale and Clare toast to their engagement. ABC Clare Crawley's Bachelorette journey came to an end mid-season when she declared Dale Moss was the only guy for her - and he agreed, popping the question with the monster ring Lane scrambled to make for him. "She had made up her mind and I had to design the ring in record time – it was stressful and crazy, but crazy fun," Lane tells PEOPLE. "I had time to make just one perfect 'Wow' ring." After a rocky few months, the two reunited and seemed happier than ever (even putting the ring back on!) — but split again for good in Sept. 2021. 07 of 28 The Ring Courtesy Neil Lane The franchise's go-to jeweler, Neil Lane, says the suitor in question chose this 3-carat oval diamond because he thought his Bachelorette bride-to-be wouldn't want a ring with "sharp edges." 08 of 28 The Reveal Hannah Brown, Jed Wyatt. Mark Bourdillon/ ABC The ring Jed Wyatt gave Hannah Brown didn't stay on her finger for long, after allegations of cheating during her season surfaced. So where's the ring now? Lane says he doesn't know: "Once they pick out the ring, it's not mine anymore no matter what happens — at that point I can only hope it brings the couple happiness." 09 of 28 The Ring Courtesy Neil Lane Pear-shaped diamonds were having a moment when this Bachelorette was proposed to with this 3-carat number. 10 of 28 The Reveal ABC Rachel Lindsay got just what she wanted when Bryan Abasolo got on one knee to offer her the on-trend sparkler: "Apparently Rachel had talked about a pear-shaped diamond and this was her fantasy ring," says Lane. "Bryan lit up when he saw it." The two tied the knot in August 2019, and Rachel received two wedding bands. 11 of 28 The Ring Courtesy Neil Lane This ring stood out from many in the Bachelor franchise due to its use of yellow gold and infinity setting. 12 of 28 The Reveal ABC A one-of-a-kind ring for a one-of-a-kind love! Garrett Yrigoyen had "a grin on his face from ear to ear" when choosing this ring for Becca Kufrin, which is "elegant and glamorous" and "represents their future." Sadly, the couple announced in Sept. 2020 that they were splitting after two years together. 13 of 28 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane The setting of this simple oval stone resembles a crown -- perfect for the groom-to-be who thought of his future bride as "his princess!" says jeweler Neil Lane. 14 of 28 THE REVEAL Matt Klitscher/ABC Bachelorette JoJo Fletcher gave her ring from Jordan Rodgers high marks for being "classic" -- and for making "my finger look skinnier, which I really appreciate," she told People. Three years later, Rodgers would propose again with a giant oval diamond on a gold band by Ring Concierge. "I always wanted to re-propose, with no cameras, no producers, no drama … just us," he said. 15 of 28 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane A 3.5-carat brilliant cut round stone in an entwined band setting was the only choice for this guy, who was a "cool customer" when it came time to pick out his Neil Lane sparkler for his Bachelorette. 16 of 28 THE REVEAL Rick Rowell/ABC Shawn Booth was confident in his decision to propose to Kaitlyn Bristowe, and for good reason - the two lasted for three years before calling it quits in 2018. 17 of 28 THE RING The Bachelorette in question was known for her spunk and sass -- but she ended up with a "feminine, soft-shaped ring" that her final pick "could see himself proposing with," Lane says. 18 of 28 THE REVEAL Javier Pesquera/ABC Though Andi Dorfman and Josh Murray were so smitten they started wedding dress shopping, their relationship went down in flames eight months later. "I was disgusted with what I put up with," Andi said. 19 of 28 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane Her ring had many of the hallmarks of a Bachelorette ring -- the halo setting around a 3.5-carat stone, the intricate diamond pavé -- but it also had the unique element of a rose gold band woven into the platinum, "just as [the winner and his fiancé] are two people wrapped into one couple and forever entwined," Lane says. 20 of 28 THE REVEAL Francisco Roman/ABC So far, Desiree Hartsock and Chris Siegfried are doing pretty well on that "forever entwined" business -- they wed in 2015 (the bride in two dresses she designed herself) and are proud parents of two. 21 of 28 THE RING Neil Lane had plenty of inspiration when designing potential rings for this Bachelorette -- she "had cut-outs from magazines of rings she'd dreamed about," Lane says, which helped the winner pick this 3.5-carat, cushion-cut sparkler valued at $60,000. 22 of 28 THE REVEAL Matt Klitscher/ABC/Getty Ashley Hebert and J.P. Rosenbaum had so much luck with her Neil Lane engagement ring, they tapped the jeweler to design their wedding bands and her bridal set as well. The two welcomed two children together, but at the end of 2020, they revealed that they'd decided to part ways. 23 of 28 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane The jeweler designed six rings with this Bachelorette in mind, but says the one the groom-to-be landed on (this 3.5-carat emerald cut diamond) was his favorite. "She exudes grace and style," Lane said of the bride. 24 of 28 THE REVEAL ABC Jef Holm slipped the sparkler onto Emily Maynard's finger in Curacao, but the two split within a few months. At the time, Maynard was heartbroken, but she's since remarried and is now a mother of four! 25 of 28 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane This $60,000, 2.05-carat pear-shaped diamond (accented by six baguette diamonds) was a bold choice for an equally bold brunette. 26 of 28 THE REVEAL Mario Perez/ABC Jillian Harris was "devastated" to find that Ed Swiderski was cheating on her after proposing in 2009. But with a baby on the way and a job hosting HGTV's Love It or List It, Too, she's left that relationship (and the ring, which she reportedly had to return) in her rearview mirror. 27 of 28 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane This 3.03-carat Asscher-cut stone, estimated at $50,000 was perfect for the "girly and sophisticated" bride-to-be -- and Lane's favorite ring was also the top choice of the eventual winner. 28 of 28 THE REVEAL Chris Chavira/ABC Though Ali Fedotowksy was "so happy" to receive a ring from Roberto Martinez, they split after a tempestuous 18 months. Not to worry, though -- she got another Neil Lane ring in 2015 when her now-husband Kevin Manno proposed.