The stars wear the same dress months apart -- but who wore it best?

Startraks; FilmMagic

File this under totally random: Rachael Ray and Kim Kardashian wore the same black Marc Bouwer dress.

The reality star first donned the curve-hugging number last year on the Late Show with David Letterman. Kanye‘s main squeeze sexed up the look with a few of her signatures, including bombshell hair, black platforms and smokey eye makeup.

Television chef Ray — who wore the dress to the Daytime Emmy Awards this weekend — opted for a pair of T-strap sandals and a graphic clutch to complete her look.

The dress in question isn’t all that unexpected for Kardashian (who’s a Faceoff regular), but it’s definitely not something we’d expect the usually demure Ray to wear. So you tell us: Who wore it better? Vote in our poll below!

–Jennifer Cress