Lifestyle Style Fashion Faceoff To kick off your Fourth of July weekend, we have a super-patriotic showdown. Plus, two stars in a crazy-sexy cutout dress and more celeb matchups that need your attention By Brittany Talarico Brittany Talarico Brittany Talarico is PEOPLE's Deputy Style Director, where she oversees the brand's digital Style and Beauty coverage. This includes running lead on the Met Gala, which is among PEOPLE.com's top-trafficked red carpet events every year, interviewing the industry's top influencers (including all the Kardashian-Jenners), and breaking A-list celeb news (a New Jersey shore native, it is no surprise that her favorite interview ever was with Bruce Springsteen). Brittany is a style contributor to People Every Day Podcast and has represented the brand on national TV programs including Good Morning America and The CW's two TV specials on the British Royals. She joined PEOPLE from Cosmopolitan in 2013, where she was an Associate Editor. People Editorial Guidelines Published on July 2, 2014 10:00 AM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 73 KENDALL VS. KHLOé VS. KYLIE Alo Ceballos/GC; Splah News Online; FameFlynet Take a break from talking about Kim’s wedding dress and vote on her sisters in these Steve Madden “Troopa” combat boots, which they all style in their own ’90s-inspired way. 02 of 73 ELIZABETH VS. JORDIN AKM-GSI; Kevin Mazur/WireImage These ladies prove Diane von Furstenberg knows how to make a very flattering dress, and we have a feeling voting on their “Zarita” lace sheath might be the hardest decision you’ll make all week (aside from debating on whether to splurge on one for yourself.) 03 of 73 SOFIA VS. NINA Ramey; Frederick M. Brown/Getty The director and actress both pair this silver studded Michael Kors dress with black ankle-strap sandals, but the Vampire Diaries star adds a unique accessory in the form of a girlie hair bow. 04 of 73 JANE VS. ANGELINA Pascal Le Segretain/Getty; Jason Merritt/Getty What age gap? Sure Jane is old enough to be mom, but that doesn’t stop her from wowing us in this Elie Saab couture gown, which the Maleficent actress wore in a similar style to the Oscars. 05 of 73 DWYANE VS. KANYE Nathaniel S. Butler/NBAE/Getty; INF Once you stop staring at the Miami Heat star’s overalls (they deserve a good look), take a minute to focus your attention on his canvas Saint Laurent “Babycat, which of course has in his footwear collection too. 06 of 73 TORI VS. JULIANNE Splash News Online; AKM-GSI Eager to wear floral pants this season? We’d advise you to keep your shirt solid and accessories minimal like these ladies demonstrate in their bold MINKPINK “Acid Bloom. 07 of 73 ESTELLE VS. JENNIFER Gary Gershoff/Getty; David Livingston/Getty If this were a hair faceoff, Jennifer’s old Hollywood curls would definitely win. But it’s all about their green lace Ines Di Santo gown, so Estelle is still very much in the running. 08 of 73 SOPHIA VS. OLIVIA AKM-GSI; on Asadorian/Splash News Online We imagine this Calypso St. Barth “Cocoon is pretty comfortable. Like, so comfortable that it can double as a blanket, and once you put it on, you never want to take it off. Right, ladies? 09 of 73 JAMIE VS. OLIVIA All Access Photo/Splash News Online; AKM-GSI This Mink Pink “Fade Into Daisies” set is available at Nordstrom and Bloomingdale’s for under 100 bucks. We contacted the stores and unfortunately, Jamie and Olivia’s shiny hair and perfect skin are sold separately. 10 of 73 JULIANNE VS. TAYLOR AKM-GSI; Splash News Online You were probably too distracted by shorteralls and insanely long legs to notice that they’re in the same Rails “Jesse and it’s covered in tiny sailboats. 11 of 73 JESSICA VS. NAOMI Bauer-Griffin/GC Images; X17online Chambray jumpsuits are the new chambray shirts? These two Hollywood moms and their Splendid onesies almost have us convinced. (We’re also convinced to invest in a wide-brim summer hat.) 12 of 73 JAMES VS. CODY Courtesy James Franco; Theresa Bouche/Invision/AP Stars wearing other stars’ faces on their shirts is totally a thing right now. Of course puts a selfie twist on the trend with this Clashist tee. (His Memoria co-star, however, is a bit less self-involved.) 13 of 73 RITA VS. ROSIE David M. Benett/Getty; Xavier Collin/Celebrity Monitor/Splash News Online Bra or no bra? That’s the question you have to ask yourself before voting for the singer or the supermodel in this ultra-plunging Gucci gown. 14 of 73 TAYLOR VS. ZOOEY Freddy Baez/Startraks Photo; Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Imitation may be the sincerest form of flattery, but having a celebrity wear a dress you helped design is the coolest form of flattery. The gives major props to the actress by sporting a piece from the To Tommy from Zooey collection. 15 of 73 CARA VS. RIHANNA Neil P. Mockford/GC Images; Sharpshooter Images/Splash News Online On the red carpet, these two love to show a lotta skin. And off the carpet, what they love is evidently to walk around in really crazy, expensive sweatpants like this pineapple-printed Zoe Karssen pair. 16 of 73 KAT VS. ZOË Noam Galai/WireImage; Justin Campbell/Startraks Photo After you vote on which toned star nails the red T by Alexander Wang bra top and pencil skirt situation, you re probably going to be overcome with the urge to start doing crunches in front of your desk. It’s a totally normal response – don’t fight it. 17 of 73 MEL B. VS. JENA Ciao Hollywood/Splash News Online; Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic You might have been surprised that both ladies chose to style their unique orange tops with the same pants. But we’ve got news: They didn’t have a choice. Because the Roksanda Ilincic design is actually attached to those cropped black trousers. 18 of 73 MARIA VS. CANDACE JB Lacroix/GC Images; Michael Tullberg/Getty Same Bailey 44 “Defender, similar nude pumps, equally toned midsections. It’s going to be hard to make the call on this one. 19 of 73 DUCHESS CATHERINE VS. EMMA Danny Martindale/WireImage; Maciel-DR/X17online When you’re married to the future King of England, the only match for a sophisticated tweed Rebecca Taylor jacket is the equally sophisticated knee-length skirt that goes with it. When you’re a young Hollywood actress, it’s totally cool to dress it down with jeans and boots. 20 of 73 IMAN VS.HEIDI Gilbert Carrasquillo/FilmMagic; Michael Buckner/Getty They’ve both ruled magazine covers, fashion campaigns and catwalks and now these two iconic supermodels are going head-to-head in the same low-cut Michael Kors dress. 21 of 73 NIKKI VS. BRIDGET Andrew Toth/Getty; D Dipasupil/Getty LBD races are always tough, especially when both stars look this good in the lace-embellished Lela Rose design. So you may want to make your decision based on their hair: down or up? 22 of 73 HOLLAND VS. EMMY Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic; Michael Simon/Startraks These actresses have one hand in their pockets and the other one, well, just hanging out and looking chic, which seems impossible not to do in this Erin Fetherston floral dress. 23 of 73 DUCHESS CATHERINE VS. MINDY Anthony Devlin/Pool/Getty; Courtesy Mindy Kaling “UHH, Miss Duchess Whoever, I WORE this dress last week! What’s next? Kate in my donut print pajama bottoms I mean c’mon,” the TV star quipped on Instagram after the sported the same poppy-print L.K. Bennett design as Mindy’s character did on The Mindy Project. 24 of 73 LESLIE VS. LUPITA Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic; Alexi Lubomirski Maybe it’s not fair to pit someone against the World’s Most Beautiful Woman, but both the actress and the Oscar winner look too amazing not to talk about in this orchid crop top and coordinating poppy skirt (both Monique Lhuillier). 25 of 73 ROSIE VS. SARAH JESSICA Splash News Online; Gary Gershoff/WireImage What has two thumbs, three names and a studded Saint Laurent topper? These girls. 26 of 73 JAMIE VS. KRISTEN Mike Coppola/Getty; Taylor Hill/Getty Anyone else just make a note in their iPhones to buy a mesh skirt like this Elizabeth and James one? Our Celeb Style Council member adds some color to the black-and-white bottom via a red blazer and fancy shoes, while the Frozen star goes for a more matchy-matchy vibe. 27 of 73 JENNIFER VS. LEA VS. EMMY AKM-GSI; John Shearer/Invision/AP; Gary Miller/FilmMagic If you’re going to invest the $1,495 on these studded Jimmy Choo “Abel, you want to make sure you have the right dress in your closet to wear them with. Oh, and toned legs evidently wouldn’t hurt either. 28 of 73 NAOMI VS. JORDANA Bauer-Griffin/GC; AKM-GSI Something we’re noticing in Hollywood right now: Overalls and a tee are the new jeans and a tee. And if you’re not ready to accept this and welcome the look into your wardrobe, just vote on and Jordana, who both cuff the Madewell “Parker. 29 of 73 JANUARY VS. NIKKI Araya Diaz/WireImage; Bauer-Griffin/GC If you often find yourself going straight from errands to the red carpet, you might consider getting this leopard Smythe “Lab (which teams as well with white skinnies, a sweater and Cons as it does with all black and red pumps). 30 of 73 KYLIE VS. VANESSA Splash News Online; Pacific Coast News It makes sense that the Coachella newbie (the Jenner sister) would look to the unofficial queen of the event () for festival fashion inspiration. And it’s not just the Milk the Goat crop top and short-shorts the reality star copied; she also did the massive flower crown thing. 31 of 73 SELENA VS. BUSY FameFlynet; Courtesy Matt Bernson Here’s a perfect example of how the same jumpsuit can look either very cool or perfectly polished, all depending on the accessories. The goes for the former with a denim jacket and chunky sandals, while the Cougar Town actress keeps things sleek with a black blazer and peep-toe booties. 32 of 73 MENA VS. KALEY Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic; Frazer Harrison/Getty We’d tell you which actress we think looks more stylish in this laser-cut Sachin + Babi maxi, but we’re too busy picturing the skirt on ourselves. 33 of 73 DITA VS. ELIZABETH Steve Granitz/Wireimage; Xavier Collin/Celebrity Monitor/Splash New Online The Maria Lucia Hohan illusion gown is smokin’ hot. The ladies in the gown are smokin’ hot. So, it all just comes down to which color you prefer. 34 of 73 LILY VS. JOURDAN VS. KHLOé Remember in high school when you and your friends all wanted to buy the same shirt at the mall? Well, that’s happening now in Hollywood. Every day someone new steps out in this Alexander Wang “Parental Advisory” mesh sweatshirt. And every day our jaws drop when we remember how much it costs ($1,075!). 35 of 73 JENNIFER VS. SOPHIA Courtesy FOX; Stefanie Keenan/Getty At first glance, you might think these are two different dresses. But it’s one (we checked). surprisingly removes the bling, while Sophia sticks with the stone embellishments on the lacy H&M Conscious Collection design. 36 of 73 NIKKI VS. OLIVIA Splash News Online; Rachel Murray/Wireimage One striped sweater. Two very different ways to wear it. Nikki incorporates the Heartloom topper into her workout gear, while Olivia pairs hers with jeans and boots at an event. (Like we said, very different.) 37 of 73 HILARY VS. ALESSANDRA X17online; FameFlynet We expect to see lots more overall faceoffs after Coachella, but for now focus your attention on the and in the same Black Orchid pair. 38 of 73 GRETA VS. STELLA Jemal Countess/Getty; Kevin Mazur/WireImage This onesie matchup is way more fancy. The France Ha actress takes on the fashion designer in a lace jumpsuit from her very own collection – bold move. 39 of 73 JANUARY VS. BEYONCé Frazer Harrison/Getty; Bauer-Griffin Buying this nautical striped Topshop dress is a no-brainer – it’s affordable and both the Mad Men and the own it – but choosing who wins isn’t going to be that easy. 40 of 73 MINDY VS. VANESSA Frederick M. Brown/Getty; Michael Simon/Startraks Photo We’re developing a new show. It’s called The Crop Top Project, and it’s time to cast a leading lady: Will it be Mindy or , who both give good midriff in the same Topshop ensemble. 41 of 73 KIM VS. SHANTEL Santi/Splash News Online; Luke Vachon/Splash News Online The Panty Flash used to be one of celebs’ greatest red carpet fears, but now baring your briefs is the goal, as proven by the and the actress in this see-through Rachel Roy midi. 42 of 73 RIHANNA VS. LILY X17online; AKM-GSI The last denim skirt we owned was from Abercrombie & Fitch, and we thought the $60 price tag was steep. But the and actress give a whole new meaning to premium denim in this flouncy hem Givenchy design, which will set you back $1,450. 43 of 73 JENNIFER VS. KATE Courtesy FOX; Paul A. Hebert/Press Line Photos/Splash News Online If this were a hair faceoff, would win (we have a weak spot for a good fishtail). But this is about their Safiyaa dresses. The American Idol judge goes for the shorter pale-blue version, while the Divergent star opts for the red gown. 44 of 73 ALESSANDRA VS. KIM Daniel Robertson/Startraks Photo; Splash News Online Alessandra challenges crop top reign (if anyone can do it, it’s a supermodel) in the same ribbed knit Calvin Klein Collection set. The million dollar question is: belt or no belt? 45 of 73 NAYA VS. RIHANNA FameFlynet; X17online Our favorite sweatpants cost about $20, but when you have a hit show or a multi-platinum album career, these $158 cotton Twenty bottoms are apparently a no-brainer. 46 of 73 JOURDAN VS. ASHLEY Raymond Hall/GC Images; David M. Benett/Getty When going bold with a green sequin pencil skirt like this Topshop one, it’s best to keep things simple on top. Both the supermodel and actress do just that in a moto-jacket-tee combo and basic black sweater, respectively. 47 of 73 ASHLEY VS. NIKKI Fitzroy Barrett/Celebrity Photo; All Access Photo/Splash News Online Scalloped edges. Black ankle tie. The Bionda Castana “Rosario” shoes are the white pumps’ sexy older sister. But do you like them with a matching mini on the Pretty Little Liars actress or with a striped midi and blazer on our Celeb Style Council member? 48 of 73 KIM VS. KYLIE Courtesy Kim Kardashian; Courtesy Kylie Jenner “Yep stole Kylie’s bikini…she’s not getting it back,” the captioned her sexy selfie after swiping her baby sister’s Lolli cutout swimsuit. 49 of 73 RIHANNA VS. JENNIFER Marc Piasecki/GC Images; FameFlynet From bikinis to puffer coats. and wrap up in the same belted Miu Miu topper, but pair the piece with completely different shoes: classic Chucks and snow boots, respectively. 50 of 73 NIKKI VS. CHRISSY VS. ALI Startracks Photo (3) If there’s one thing you take away from this Faceoff, we hope it’s the Old Navy pants. Seriously, buy them now (we have). They’re only $30 and you can brag to your friends about how you own the same pair that all the celebs wear. 51 of 73 JAIME VS. LINDSAY VP/Star Max/GC Images; Alo Ceballos/GC Images This Rag & Bone sweater is named the “Talia,” but if we wore it with white sneakers and basic blue jeans, we’d refer to it as the Jaime, or with ripped white skinnies and pumps, the 52 of 73 GWYNETH VS. TAYLOR AKM-GSI; mpi63/MediaPunch is married to a rocker, and Taylor is a rocker. They’re both blonde. We thought the similarities ended there, until we spotted both stars in this red-and-black Alice + Olivia topper. 53 of 73 TAYLOR VS. KATE Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic (2) Fun Faceoff fact: wore this black sequin Julien Macdonald gown to the Vanity Fair post-Oscars party in 2011 and brought it back three years later for the same event! 54 of 73 RIHANNA VS. NOOMI Sipa; AKM-GSI That awkward moment when you show up to the Givenchy Paris Fashion Week show in the same striped jacket from the brand that another star is wearing. (You know what it’s like, right? No? Yeah, neither do we.) Luckily, added a bra top, backwards baseball cap and veil, while Noomi went for a more understated vibe. 55 of 73 RITA VS. KIERNAN Chelsea Lauren/WireImage; Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic Surprised that a 57-year-old actress and a 14-year-old starlet have similar taste in dresses? Well, here’s another surprise: They both style their Prada design with ankle-strap shoes from the brand. 56 of 73 AMY VS. JAIME Michael Simon/Startraks (2) This striped tweed jacket can be kept casual with basic skinnies (on Amy) or dressed up with a leather mini (see Jaime). Plus, it’s under $100, so after you cast your vote, you might want to treat yourself and nab one. 57 of 73 KATY VS. JOURDAN Jun Sato/WireImage; Kirstin Sinclair/Getty “I’m lovin’ it:” We imagine McDonalds’s famous tagline describes exactly how the and supermodel feel about the Moschino sweatshirt dress inspired by the fast food franchise. 58 of 73 LUPITA VS. JENNIFER FayesVision/WENN; FameFlynet These actresses were both nominated for Best Styling of the Sophia Webster “Coco” Heel. And it’s time for you – the prestigious members of the PeopleStyleWatch.com Academy – to choose a winner. 59 of 73 HILARY VS. KHLOé Vladimir Labissiere/Splash News Online; Milton Ventura/Broadimage Clearly these two don’t follow the “No White Jeans Before Memorial Day Rule” code, choosing to wear their distressed Frame denim bottoms early in season. But which one is the more stylish rule-breaker? 60 of 73 PAZ VS. CATE Venturelli/WireImage; Tullio M. Puglia/Getty While we’re busy trying to track down the secret to their flawless complexions and shiny hair, make sure to vote on Paz and in their long-sleeve Gucci dresses. 61 of 73 JOURDAN VS. JENNIFER David M. Benett/Getty; Michael Tran/FilmMagic They don’t pop Molly, they rock Tom Ford. Think the two of them sang that Jay Z song while posing in front of the mirror in their honeycomb turtleneck minis by the designer? 62 of 73 MIRANDA VS. KIM Splash News Online; James Devaney/WireImage This isn’t the first time the and the have faced off in a crazy-expensive Saint Laurent item. Remember these $2,390 chain-embellished jeans? Now, it’s a $3,528 leather jacket, obviously. 63 of 73 LIZZY VS. KATE Araya Diaz/WireImage; Jason Merritt/Getty We don’t know which actress makes the bolder statement: Lizzy, who pairs her printed Parker pants with lace-up boots or , who opts for neon pumps. 64 of 73 GLORIA VS. SHOSHANNA Splash News Online; Courtesy HBO What’s better than a swimsuit showdown? A swimsuit showdown involving two of our favorite TV characters and a $450 Agent Provocateur monokini. (We really wish a Girls emoji existed for the colorful one piece.) 65 of 73 PARIS VS. PEYTON Rex; Splash News Online This lip-print Alice + Olivia dress must come with specific instructions on how to pose. You can tell the and actress are both dying to twirl around in the girlie design. 66 of 73 GWEN VS. BRITNEY AKM-GSI; Niki Nikolova/FilmMagic No, didn’t sport a feather scrunchie and no, didn’t wear a bindi. They’re just facing off in this classic Smythe coat. 67 of 73 ZENDAYA VS. MIROSLAVA Frederick M. Brown/Getty; Venturelli/WireImage The singer-actress and the Russian fashion editor have more than just exotically cool names in common. They also both share a love of this metallic Gucci suit (though they each style it very differently). 68 of 73 AMY VS. NAOMI GVK/Bauer-Griffin; Splash News Online When these actresses aren’t going all-out glam in major gowns or transforming themselves for roles, they like to get casual and cozy in the same way: with a striped Inhabit cashmere sweater. 69 of 73 CARA VS. ALESSANDRA Splash News Online; AKM-GSI Skinny jeans are to supermodels what crop tops are to : necessary. The two pro posers keep things interesting with their denim choices: a pair of animal-print BlankNYC bottoms (which are on sale now!). 70 of 73 VIVICA VS. GWYNETH Tony DiMaio/Startraks Photo; Richard Young/Rex USA There are two types of crop top wearers: The ones who show off a slice of skin (like Vivica, who pairs her Jason Wu design with a high-waist pencil skirt), and the ones who show off full-on navel (see: ). And there is one type of person who owns this crop top: someone with $3,327 to burn. 71 of 73 ASHLEY VS. GIULIANA Michael Bezjian/Wireimage; Jon Kopaloff/Filmmagic This Three Floor dress may be named “Behaviour Self,” but the actress and TV host both look more sassy and fun than sweet and proper in the cutout design. 72 of 73 MARY VS. BEYONCé Paul Bruinooge/Patrick McMullan/Sipa; Prince Williams/Filmmagic We often wonder what it would be like to walk in a platinum recording artist’s shoes, but we have a feeling the answer is uncomfortable when the shoes in question are these over-the-knee Christian Dior boots. 73 of 73 ABBIE VS. GABRIELLE Ramey (2) Peep-toe pumps or moto boots: Which look best with black skinnies? That’s the question you need to be asking yourself when deciding between the actresses in their coated James Jeans bottoms.