Lifestyle Style Fashion Faceoff Sometimes, stylish star minds think alike. You decide: Who wears it better? Vote on Jennifer Lopez, Emmy Rossum and more By People Staff Published on January 4, 2007 07:35 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 12 JENNIFER VS. MARIBEL eroimagen/lfi; Jason Merritt/FilmMagic The El Cantante star stepped out in Madrid this fall in her silver Max Mara, while the Pan’s Labyrinth actress shimmered in her sequined frock at the film’s L.A. premiere a few months later. 02 of 12 EMMY VS. WHITNEY Henry Lamb/Photowire/BEImages; Michael Tran/FilmMagic The actress got ruffled in her 3.1 Philip Lim sheath at a MAC event in New York in September, while The Hills cast member recently celebrated the show’s second season in the one-shouldered frock in L.A. 03 of 12 AMY VS. TILDA Roger Wong/inf; RAMEY Evanescence singer Amy Lee got puffed-up in her Viktor & Rolf coat during a shopping trip in Toronto, while the Chronicles of Narnia actress was seriously bundled up while out and about in L.A. 04 of 12 JENNIFER VS. GWYNETH Peter Kramer/Getty; Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic The recent Golden Globe winner glowed in her Prada dress at a Late Show taping, while the Oscar winner looked lovely in her pale version of the satin frock at an Estee Lauder luncheon. 05 of 12 JESSICA VS. HILARY Biel lit up the Golden Globes red carpet in her beaded Valentino gown, but Swank had already donned the same dress three years before for an Oscars party. 06 of 12 LIZZY VS. PARIS Sara De Boer/Retna; Devan/INF The Class star worked a casual vibe at the People’s Choice Awards in her Tricia Fix dress, while the heiress went for hippie chic at a summer charity event in L.A. 07 of 12 FERGIE VS. HILARY Kevin Winter/Getty;Orlando Garcia/jpi Same night, same dress! The “Fergalicious” singer rang in the New Year by performing in her Tory Burch sequined dress, while the newly single star celebrated in Miami in the same minidress accessorized with ankle boots. 08 of 12 KELLY VS. KELLIE Can Nguyen/Capital Pictures/GAMMA; Laura Farr/AdMedia The Osbournes star looked elegant in her draped Donna Karan gown at a film premiere in London, while the former Idol was regal in her purple dress at the CMA awards a few weeks earlier in Nashville. 09 of 12 LINDSAY VS. JULIE Sara De Boer/Retna Ltd; Photopro/Landov The fashionista bloomed in her floral Diane von Furstenberg frock at a party in L.A., while the mom-to-beglowed in hers at an event honoring Boston Legal in Beverly Hills. 10 of 12 DREW VS. JENNA Baxter/ABACA;inf The Music and Lyrics star wore her swingy Diane von Furstenberg frock to an L.A. event earlier this fall, while the Courting Alex actress chose her velvet dress for a night out in Rome before Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes’s wedding. 11 of 12 SARAH JESSICA VS. AUNDREA ST/Splash News;Arlene Richie/jpistudios The actress shimmered in metallic Dolce & Gabbana at the New York City premiere of The Devil Wears Prada – while the Danity Kane singer wore her minidress to the Billboard Awards in Las Vegas 12 of 12 NATALIE VS. DANNII VS. IVANKA Sylvain Gaboury/FilmMagic; Bill Davila/startraks;Jon Furniss/WireImage Good things really do come in threes! Dixie Chicks singer Maines (left) hit the red carpet in her Dolce & Gabbana frock at a New York City film screening the day after The Apprentice star (right) stepped out in her chain-laden dress to a Big Apple charity benefit. A month later, Aussie pop-star Minogue wore hers to the London premiere of Casino Royale.