People.com
Style
Fashion Faceoff

Fashion Faceoff

Sometimes, stylish star minds think alike. You decide: Who wears it better?

By Alex Apatoff

Updated January 25, 2011 09:20 PM

Skip gallery slides

1 of 30

CAMERON VS. TAYLOR

Credit: Michael Becker/PictureGroup/FOX; Rick Diamond/Getty

The paired her sweet Jenny Packham frock with loose locks on American Idol in April, while the opted for pinned-up curls at a CMT event.

2 of 30

SARAH MICHELLE VS. DIANE

Credit: Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage; ANG/Fame

The former Buffy got glam in a flirty Chanel frock back in 2007, while the German stunner lost the overlay at a Chanel show in Paris this month.

3 of 30

ISLA VS. CHRISTINA

Credit: Joanne Davidson/PictureGroup; Fotonoticias/WireImage

Better off red! While both stars beat the chill by pairing their Dolce & Gabbana dresses with tights and blazers, grabbed a clutch in London, while added a belt in Madrid.

Continued on next slide.

4 of 30

MICHELLE VS. MARIA

Credit: Stephen Lovekin/Getty; Donato Sardella/WireImage

The actress kept her Alice + Olivia floral-print simple at the Blue Valentine N.Y.C. premiere, while the TV host added nude pumps and a pretty headband at a party for the line.

5 of 30

MALIN VS. CHERYL

Credit: George Pimentel/WireImage; Ken McKay/TalkbackThames/Rex

The actress struck a dramatic pose in J. Mendel at the Toronto International Film Festival, while the X Factor judge made a glamorous turn on the TV show.

6 of 30

KRISTIN VS. ANNALYNNE

Credit: JCalderon/Splash News Online; Angela Weiss/Getty

went out in style in a cut-out Donna Mizani frock and sandals while filming the last season of The Hills, while the 90210 star showed off her toned figure and kept the focus on the frock with simple pumps.

Continued on next slide.

7 of 30

KATE VS. HILARY

Credit: INF; Flynet

The was cosmically inclined in Acne’s celestial tee, which she wore with a blazer and chain-strap bag for dinner in London, while the took a more casual approach in a different version of the starry shirt, pairing it with leather leggings and a cozy scarf.

8 of 30

HALLE VS. PARIS

Credit: BuzzFoto; Bauer-Griffin

Fangs for the memories! The Frankie & Alice let her tee do the talking when running errands in L.A., while gave a toothy grin in her Wildfox Couture sweatshirt, which she paired with a cozy robe and relaxed tresses.

9 of 30

ALESSANDRA VS. WINONA

Credit: Sipa; Stephen Lovekin/WireImage

The Victoria’s Secret babe was on model behavior in her striking, full-skirted Dolce & Gabbana frock, which she wore with a simple gold necklace, while the Black Swan amped up the drama in strappy pumps, drop earrings and dark eyeliner.

Continued on next slide.

10 of 30

ANNA VS. CAREY

Credit: INF; Sipa

One fierce faceoff! The Vogue editrix prowled the streets of Paris in an animal-print Lanvin frock, which she wore with nude peep-toes and a salmon sweater, while the Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps star glammed it up with caramel platform pumps and a stunning statement necklace.

11 of 30

RIHANNA VS. EMMA

Credit: Flynet; Arnaldo Magnani/Getty

toned down her typically Loud style in her gray Vince sweater while out in N.Y.C., while the Harry Potter paired hers with a relaxed buffalo-check top en route The Late Show with David Letterman.

12 of 30

JENNY VS. EVA

Credit: INF; Gilbert Flores/CelebrityPhoto

accentuated the sexy one-shoulder silhouette by pulling her hair up for the American Music Awards, while maximized her Stella McCartney with eye-catching gold accessories at the MTV Movie Awards.

Continued on next slide.

13 of 30

WINONA VS. REBECCA

Credit: Gregorio T. Binuya/Everett; Pacific Coast News

The Black Swan showed off her assets in a corset top and circle skirt from Louis Vuitton at the Toronto premiere of the film, while the British actress kept her ladylike dress simple at the Evening Standard Theater Awards in London.

14 of 30

VANESSA VS. OLIVIA

Credit: Clark Samuels/Startraks; Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic

Beautiful in beige! The newly engaged wore nude pumps and a down do to complement her Alice + Olivia by Stacey Bendet dress while filming Good Day New York,, while the TV host dressed hers up with strappy gold sandals at a L.A. event.

15 of 30

KOURTNEY VS. COLBIE

Credit: Jason Merritt/Getty; Jesse Grant/Getty

We’re seeing a pattern here! Kourtney added simple black pumps to offset her French Connection mini while out in West Hollywood, while the “Bubbly” singer opted for bow-embellished peep-toes at a L.A. event.

Continued on next slide.

16 of 30

KIM VS. VANESSA

Credit: Jackson Lee/Splash News Online; IONU/X17online

The jewelry took a walk on the wild side in her Style Stalker “Snakebite” leggings and blazer, while the covered hers with boots and a jacket.

17 of 30

RIHANNA VS. DIANE

Credit: Mavrix; Machette/INF

The Bajan prowled the Barbados beaches in her We Are Handsome Amazon suit and cardigan, while the actress stayed sun-safe in a scarf and fedora in Mexico.

18 of 30

HAYDEN VS. TARAJI

Credit: API/Fame; Ethan Miller/WireImage

The Heroes star added edge to her Elizabeth and James ruffled mini with a leather jacket and bold lips, while the actress dared to bare, pairing hers with shiny gold accessories.

Continued on next slide.

19 of 30

EMMY VS. OLIVIA

Credit: Ron Asadorian/Splash News Online; National Photo Group

The Shameless star looked cozy in her cable-knit Ann Taylor cardi and boots while at the airport, while the Tron actress paired hers with a striped tee and comfy kicks in L.A.

20 of 30

LINDSAY VS. ANGIE

Credit: Adhemar Sburlati/Broadimage; Peter Kramer/AP

The Lipstick Jungle actress wore her Naeem Khan frock with a geometric clutch, while the Rizzoli and Isles star amped up the drama with a metallic bag and smoky eyes.

21 of 30

NICOLE VS. ELLEN

Credit: Denise Truscello/WireImage; MJT/AdMedia

It’s the New Year’s Eve dress! The newlywed wore own Winter Kate design on Dec. 31, 2009, while the paired hers with an updo for a Vegas bash on Dec. 30 this year.

Continued on next slide.

22 of 30

NAOMI VS. KATE

Credit: Charles Eshelman/FilmMagic; Gregg DeGuire/PictureGroup

The Aussie cropped her Stella McCartney lace-detail jumpsuit for a N.Y.C. premiere in April, while the Private Practice star went long for a L.A. event in December.

23 of 30

TAYLOR VS. ALESSANDRA

Credit: X17online; Bryan Bedder/WireImage

The Speak Now dressed down her Wildfox Couture sweater with ankle booties, while the supermodel posed in knee-high boots with her “Love Potion No. 9” top.

24 of 30

BROOKE VS. KELLY

Credit: Sara Jaye Weiss/Startraks (2)

City chic! The got sexy in SoHo in her Boden coat and suede boots while the Real Housewife wore hers with velvet harem pants and flats on N.Y.C.’s Upper East Side.

Continued on next slide.

25 of 30

MICHELLE VS. JENNI

Credit: JC Olivera/JPI; Evan Agostini/AP

The Gossip Girl star added a thin belt and metallic pumps to her IN ADD MINUS dress, while Jersey Shore’s “J-Woww” chose a wide belt and a modified Snooki-inspired pouf.

26 of 30

HILARY VS. ASHLEE

Credit: Albert Michael/Startraks; John Sciulli/WireImage

It’s in the jeans! The actress wore her J Brand “Agnes” jeans with an all-black ensemble, while the paired hers with a slouchy sweater and statement earrings – both on the same day in L.A.

27 of 30

VANESSA VS. HALLE

Credit: AKM Images; Flynet

The newly single wore her Wildfox Couture jean shorts with a floppy hat while shopping in Malibu, while the Frankie and Alice paired hers with a long-sleeved top and metallic thongs for lunch in L.A.

Continued on next slide.

28 of 30

NICKY VS. JENNA

Credit: Norman Scott/Startraks (2)

That’s a wrap! The heiress accessorized her olive Alice + Olivia mini with a leopard clutch and gladiator-inspired heels, while the actress wore her blue version with simple jewelry and basic black pumps.

29 of 30

LIV VS. CHLOE

Credit: Carmen Valdes/Photo Image Press; Billy Farrell/BFAnyc/Sipa

The went for monochromatic menswear in her Chanel sleeveless jumpsuit, black bag and brogues at a Chanel party in N.Y.C., while the style star wore the black-and-white version rolled up with boots and a coordinating clutch at a museum gala in L.A.

30 of 30

KATRINA VS. KATHARINE

Credit: Albert Michael/Startraks (2)

The 30 Rock co-star paired her American Eagle military-inspired jacket with comfy boots and utilitarian tote while shopping in N.Y.C., while the singer sported hers with glam earrings and a bright clutch in Philadelphia.
Vote on More Fashion Faceoffs >

Replay gallery

Up Next

By Alex Apatoff

Account

More

Fashion Faceoff

1 of 30

CAMERON VS. TAYLOR

1 of 30

2 of 30

SARAH MICHELLE VS. DIANE

2 of 30

3 of 30

ISLA VS. CHRISTINA

3 of 30

4 of 30

MICHELLE VS. MARIA

4 of 30

5 of 30

MALIN VS. CHERYL

5 of 30

6 of 30

KRISTIN VS. ANNALYNNE

6 of 30

7 of 30

KATE VS. HILARY

7 of 30

8 of 30

HALLE VS. PARIS

8 of 30

9 of 30

ALESSANDRA VS. WINONA

9 of 30

10 of 30

ANNA VS. CAREY

10 of 30

11 of 30

RIHANNA VS. EMMA

11 of 30

12 of 30

JENNY VS. EVA

12 of 30

13 of 30

WINONA VS. REBECCA

13 of 30

14 of 30

VANESSA VS. OLIVIA

14 of 30

15 of 30

KOURTNEY VS. COLBIE

15 of 30

16 of 30

KIM VS. VANESSA

16 of 30

17 of 30

RIHANNA VS. DIANE

17 of 30

18 of 30

HAYDEN VS. TARAJI

18 of 30

19 of 30

EMMY VS. OLIVIA

19 of 30

20 of 30

LINDSAY VS. ANGIE

20 of 30

21 of 30

NICOLE VS. ELLEN

21 of 30

22 of 30

NAOMI VS. KATE

22 of 30

23 of 30

TAYLOR VS. ALESSANDRA

23 of 30

24 of 30

BROOKE VS. KELLY

24 of 30

25 of 30

MICHELLE VS. JENNI

25 of 30

26 of 30

HILARY VS. ASHLEE