Lifestyle Style Fashion Faceoff Sometimes, stylish star minds think alike. You decide: Who wears it better? By Alex Apatoff Alex Apatoff Instagram Twitter Alex Apatoff is the Executive Editor of PEOPLE Digital. She has been with the brand for more than a decade, holding various roles on the Style and Beauty team before becoming the site's Lifestyle Director to coordinate the work across the commerce, evergreen, features and marketing teams. Prior to her role at PEOPLE, Alex worked at Us Weekly (where, among other things, she oversaw the Fashion Police pages) and graduated from Northwestern University with a Bachelors in Journalism. People Editorial Guidelines Published on August 23, 2011 10:00 AM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 45 JORDIN VS. KIM Jason Merritt/Getty; Ramey The wears her Alexander McQueen sheath with peep-toes to an L.A. event, while the adds a bright clutch and sky-high pumps in Beverly Hills.Vote on More Fashion Faceoffs > 02 of 45 PIPPA VS. LINDSAY Bauer-Griffin; AKM Images The royal bridesmaid rocks her green Temperley gown with a half-down do and clutch at her wedding reception, while the wears the white version to nuptials. 03 of 45 JENNIFER VS. MICHELLE Splash News Online; Freddy Baez/Startraks The wears her Prada dress with her favorite shades and nude pumps, while the adds a straw tote and flats. 04 of 45 EVA VS. KAREN Clint Slauding/Patrick McMullan/Sipa; Michael Loccisano/Getty The model wears her Gucci gown with black pumps in N.Y.C., while the opts a high-shine clutch and nude sandals at the Tribeca Film Festival. 05 of 45 ROSIE VS. KATE Flynet; Gerallt/Bauer-Griffin The model wears her Paige skinny jeans with thong sandals and a tee in West Hollywood, while the picks a purple sweater and flats in North Wales. 06 of 45 EMMY VS. RACHEL Flynet; BuzzFoto Emmy pairs her Robert Rodriguez sweater with a printed skirt and oversize scarf in L.A., while dons hers with a frilly mini and cross-body bag in Santa Monica, Calif. 07 of 45 JESSALYN VS. CARRIE Mark Davis/PictureGroup; Michael Germana/Landov The Glee actress wears her Capretta dress with rosette-adorned sandals at a Fox bash, while the True Blood star attends a film festival in peep-toes. 08 of 45 REESE VS. KIM Steve Granitz/WireImage; Milton Ventura/Broadimage Newlyweds face off! hits the MTV Movie Awards in a leopard Zac Posen mini and nude pumps, while adds massive black platforms while cake shopping. 09 of 45 EVA VS. CAMERON John Parra/WireImage; Flynet dresses up her J Brand skinny jeans with a glittering top and platform pumps in Miami, while goes casual in a jean jacket and sandals in London. 10 of 45 SELITA VS. VANESSA Todd Oren/WireImage; Flynet The model shows skin in her putty-hued Robin Brouillette maxi in Cannes, while the tops hers with a cuffed blazer and bangles in N.Y.C. 11 of 45 HAYDEN VS. HALLE GSI Media; INF Black Orchid cutoffs are beach-chic with an oversize tee and aviators in L.A., while get an edgy spin with a cap and graphic tee in Beverly Hills. 12 of 45 NICKY VS. ASHLEE Splash News Online; Fame The socialite goes bright in her Blu Moon kimono top and grape jeans in L.A., while the wears hers with jean shorts and a floppy hat in Sherman Oaks, Calif. 13 of 45 JENNIFER VS. RACHEL Ramey; Gonzalo/Bauer-Griffin The expectant dresses down her StyleMint tee with a ball cap and sneakers, while the CW adds a jacket, quilted bag and her favorite shoes the same day. 14 of 45 ELLEN VS. CHELSEA Fame; Christopher Peterson/BuzzFoto The wears her A.L.C. striped sweater with jeans and heeled boots in L.A., while in N.Y.C., the E! host adds a red bag and combat boots. 15 of 45 SHANTEL VS. VANESSA David Becker/WireImage; Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage The actress pairs her Rachel Roy mini with shiny gold pumps in Hollywood, while the adds a golden clutch and nude pumps for her bachelorette blowout in Las Vegas. 16 of 45 JENNA VS. SHANNON Frank Micelotta/PictureGroup; Evan Agostini/PictureGroup The Glee star wears a yellow Tibi dress with platform peep-toes in N.Y.C., while the Raising Hope actress picks a white version of the dress and basic black pumps for a bash across town the same day. 17 of 45 CIARA VS. KYLIE Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic; Can Nguyen/Capital Pictures/AdMedia Ciara leaves her Emilio Pucci mini unlaced and adds stacked nude pumps in L.A., while Kylie keeps things tied, accenting her dress with peep-toes and a clutch in London. 18 of 45 JAIME VS. EMMY Courtesy Carrera Sunglasses; Pacific Coast News Two stars who love Banana Republic’s Mad Men collection, Jaime wears her lace dress with loafers and an oversize clutch in West Hollywood, while Emmy pairs the black version with blue flats in L.A. 19 of 45 KELLY VS. LAKE Jemal Countess/Getty; Sara De Boer/Startraks The singer adds tons of metallic accessories to her Cushnie et Ochs dress in N.Y.C., while the actress lets the sexy dress take center stage with subtle additions in L.A. 20 of 45 KAT VS. KYM INF; Sara De Boer/Startraks The singer wears her La Femme dress with black pumps at an N.Y.C. party, while the dancer hits a Century City, Calif., bash in nude peep-toes and bangles. 21 of 45 LEIGHTON VS. BEYONCé Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic; Joe Schildhorn/BFAnyc/Sipa The wears her Michael Kors gown with stick-straight strands in January, while the chooses big curls and bling at New York Fashion Week. 22 of 45 KATE VS. KRIS Henry Lamb/Photowire/BEImages; Dimitrios Kambouris/WireImage The flaunts her figure in polka-dot Stella McCartney and two-tone sandals in March, while the reality mom jazzes hers up with eye-catching sparklers this month. 23 of 45 FREIDA VS. EMILY Alex J. Berliner; Dominique Charriau/WireImage Freida pairs her Louis Vuitton romper with peep-toes in L.A., while Emily gives hers edge with thigh-highs and a tassel clutch in Paris. 24 of 45 SELITA VS. GIADA Evan Agostini/AP; Steve Granitz/WireImage The model belts her Victoria Beckham sheath and adds patent pumps in N.Y.C., while the celebrity chef keeps her look light for an event in Carpinteria, Calif. 25 of 45 EMMA VS. CHELSEA Pacific Coast News; Sara De Boer/Startraks Emma tops her Aqua eyelet dress with a jean jacket and wedges in L.A., while in Beverly Hills, Chelsea keeps the look simple, adding only matching sandals. 26 of 45 ANNALYNNE VS. SELENA GSI Media; Albert Michael/Startraks The 90210 star pairs her Robert Rodriguez top with skinny jeans and a scarf in West Hollywood, while the plays it up with a houndstooth mini in N.Y.C. 27 of 45 BLAKE VS. JESSICA Donna Ward/Getty; Rex USA The dresses up her beaded Isabel Marant jacket with a ruched mini and patterned tights in N.Y.C., while the keeps hers casual with jean shorts and pumps, also in N.Y.C. 28 of 45 NAOMI VS. CHARLIZE Hector Vallenilla/Pacific Coast News; Copetti/Startraks Hopping on Hollywood’s hottest trend, Naomi wears her Express jeans with her favorite shoes in N.Y.C., while Charlize wears hers in London with a jacket and pumps. 29 of 45 TERRI VS. KELLY Brian To/FilmMagic; Fame The TV presenter wears Aurelio Costarella with nude Mary Janes in L.A., while the singer opts for platform pumps and a bracelet in Hollywood. 30 of 45 ALICE VS. NICKY Pacific Coast News; Fame The actress accessorizes her Madewell dress with a scarf, hat and sandals in L.A., while the socialite keeps it simple with wedges and a sea-foam bag in Malibu, Calif. 31 of 45 EMMA VS. JESSICA Paul Drinkwater/NBC/AP; INF Emma visits The Tonight Show in a Dolce & Gabbana dress with contrasting chartreuse pumps, while Jessica stays cozy in N.Y.C. with a sweater and simple sling backs. 32 of 45 SARAH JESSICA VS. ALEXA Jamie McCarthy/WireImage; Fame N.Y.C.’s wears her Proenza Schouler frock with a pink tuxedo jacket and fab heels, while Britian’s fashionista dons bow-adorned flats and red lips at the line’s fashion show. 33 of 45 EVA VS. VICTORIA Bill Davila/Startraks; Jackson Lee/Splash News Online The plays up the sweet side of her Victoria Beckham dress with champagne pumps, while her wears her own design with sultry shades and platforms. 34 of 45 RACHEL VS. KIRSTEN Mauer/Broadimage; Limelight styles her Alexa Chung for Madewell shorts with a tee and funky sandals, while picks a crew neck and girlie flats. 35 of 45 ROSARIO VS. LEONA Gregg DeGuire/PictureGroup; Xposure The actress belts her Diane von Furstenberg column in the front and adds charcoal pumps, while the singer ties hers in the back and finishes the look with red lipstick and a big ring. 36 of 45 KENDRA VS. KRISTIN Bill Davila/Startraks; Flynet wears her Ani Lee blouse with a jacket and pencil skirt for daytime in N.Y.C., while plays with bold color-blocking at night in Hollywood. 37 of 45 RACHEL VS. MICHELLE Jack/X17online; Matei H/GVK/Bauer-Griffin dresses down her hot-pink AG skinny jeans with a tank and slip-ons in Hollywood, while Michelle gives hers an urban twist with a jacket and booties in Toronto. 38 of 45 JESSICA VS. GWEN Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic; Carlos Roque/Broadimage The actress wears her Banana Republic Mad Men Collection tank with funky khakis and booties, while the plays up the retro vibe with a sweet headband and cropped jeans. 39 of 45 MARIA VS. ANNIE Christopher Peterson/BuzzFoto; Pacific Coast News The TV presenter wears her Baby Phat maxi with a chain-strap bag in N.Y.C., while the Charlie’s Angels actress goes boho in Miami with an oversize bag and fedora. 40 of 45 CIARA VS. EVA Pacific Coast News; Stuart Wilson/Getty The singer stuns in a sheer Emilio Pucci dress and black pumps in Paris, while the actress wears hers lined and with strappy sandals for a London premiere. 41 of 45 KATE VS. FERGIE Getty (2) The struts in Louis Vuitton lace-up boots, while the tones her outfit down with tights. 42 of 45 MEGAN VS. GISELE Xposure; Splash News Online The adds a cognac bag and boots to her Rails button-up, while the picks dark denim and classic shades. 43 of 45 LEIGHTON VS. BEATRICE Jason Merritt/Getty; Venturini/Angelini/Bauer-Griffin The wears her Elie Saab frock with matching dusty blue sandals in Beverly Hills, while the royal adds metallic pumps for a wedding in Italy. 44 of 45 ASHLEY VS. RUTINA FilmMagic (2) adds stacked black pumps to her Farah Angsana mini in Madrid, while Rutina gives hers edge with funky beige sandals in Hollywood. 45 of 45 HAYDEN VS. NICKY Ramey; Lisa Rose/Zuma The toughens up her J Brand jeans with motorcycle boots and a studded belt at LAX, while the designer keeps hers classic with pointy pumps at a West Hollywood event.