Lifestyle Style Fashion Faceoff Sometimes, stylish star minds think alike. You decide: Who wears it better? By People Staff Published on May 6, 2008 09:00 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 43 BLAKE VS. CAMERON Abbot/Daniel/INF; LimeLight It’s the hot date dress! Lively wore her Rag & Bone tunic out for dinner with boyfriend Penn Badgley in New York, while a few days later Diaz got cozy with model Paul Sculfor in her blue-and-white minidress. 02 of 43 KRISTIN VS. JADA VS. KATE Malcolm Taylor/Getty; Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic; Martin McNeil/WireImage Three-peat! Cavallari turned up in her Monique Lhuillier dress at the MuchMusic Awards in Toronto two days before Pinkett Smith wore her metallic strapless to an awards dinner in Los Angeles. And Mara hit the Edinburgh International Film Festival in her pewter dress just four days later. 03 of 43 LIV VS. SALMA Matei H/Friolo/JRI/Bauer-Griffin; Fame The Incredible Hulk star got comfy in her Juicy Couture maxidress while strolling in L.A., while the new mom took her daughter Valentina shopping in her paisley-print dress a week later. 04 of 43 MILA VS. PARIS Rob Loud/Getty; James Devaney/WireImage The Forgetting Sarah Marshall star got into the graphic print trend in her Alice + Olivia dress at a fashion party in N.Y.C. in May, while the reality-show star turned up for a night of taping in her black-and-white frock. 05 of 43 KERRY VS. MOLLY Johns PkI/Splash News; Jeff Gentner/Getty Washington was elegant in silver Tory Burch at the ACE Awards in New York City, while Sims sizzled in her metallic tunic at a Kentucky Derby party. 06 of 43 EVA VS. KIM Chris Pizzello/AP; ttl/Capital/Retna The Desperate Housewives star hit the Golden Globes in 2007 in her Emanuel Ungaro dress, while the reality star showed off her famous curves in her navy beaded gown in Monaco this week. 07 of 43 GWEN VS. LIV Kevin Mazur/Wireimage; Paul Drinkwater/NBCU The stylish mom-to-be got wrapped up in her Lanvin dress at a charity event last October, while the Incredible Hulk star promoted her film in her navy belted dress on The Tonight Show. 08 of 43 BEYONCé VS. MONICA Steve Granitz/Wireimage; Lalo Yasky/ Wireimage The newlywed vamped it up at the Golden Globes in 2007 in her golden Elie Saab gown, while Penélope Cruz’s little sister stole the spotlight in her plunging gown at the Elle Awards in Barcelona this week. 09 of 43 SELMA VS. KATE Graylock/ABACA;Flynet The actress cut a stylish figure in her Marc Jacobs dress at the designer’s show in February, while the supermodel enjoyed a night out in Berlin this week in her crystal-studded minidress. 10 of 43 CHRISTINA VS. KELLY Goff/INF; Mike Marsland/Wireimage The Samantha Who? star worked her Donna Karan dress at the American Music Awards last November, while the former Destiny’s Child singer strutted down the red carpet red carpet at Sex and the City’s London premiere in her purple strapless dress in May. 11 of 43 JESSICA VS. EVA Gabriel S/Matthew S/Bauer-Griffin; Keith/NPG The new lingerie designer takes off from San Diego with boyfriend Tony Romo in her Juicy Couture dress, while the actress snuggles up to her guy Tony Parker in her floral maxidress as they depart from JFK a few days later. 12 of 43 FERGIE VS. MARY Kevin Mazur/WireImage; Fred Duval/FilmMagic Battle of the divas! Fergie hit the Grammys stage in her Versace gown back in February, while Blige was elegant in her neutral gown at the Raisa Gorbachev Foundation party in London this week. 13 of 43 PAULA VS. JENNIFER David Longdyke/Globe;PhotoXpress/ZUMA The actress glittered in her Gucci dress at the Soul Train awards in 2007, while the new mom sizzled in her metallic mini at the MuzTV music awards in Moscow this week. 14 of 43 AUDRINA VS. JENNY Francis Specker /Landov; Mavrix The reality star showed off her assets in her Black Halo dress at a Superbowl party, while the actress hit a blackjack tournament in the Bahamas this week in her colorblocked one. 15 of 43 PARIS VS. KRIS dpa /Landov; Ramey The heiress arrived to a German TV show in her Diane von Furstenberg dress in March, while the Keeping Up with the Kardashians matriarch wore her vivid maxidress to a charity event in Beverly Hills in May. 16 of 43 LINDSAY VS. SARAH JESSICA Wenn; Janet Mayer/Splash News Lohan wore this metallic Nina Ricci gown with a leather jacket for a photo shoot in L.A. last winter, while Parker unknowingly hit the red carpet in the same gown for the N.Y.C. Sex and the City premiere. (Click here for the full story on the controversy.) 17 of 43 AUDRINA VS. HEIDI Charley Gallay/Getty; It’s a Hills smackdown! Patridge heated up Maxim’s Hot 100 party in her yellow Hervé Légér, while Montag opted for the maroon version for the MTV Movie Awards a week later. 18 of 43 SHARON VS. MARY Starface/Retna; Demis Maryannakis/Splash News The controversial actress steps up in her Marchesa dress in Cannes, while the singer hits a high note in her black and white frock at the Sex and the City premiere in New York. 19 of 43 AMANDA VS. CHRISTINA Gregg DeGuire/WireImage; Jordan Strauss/WireImage The young star heated up a Hollywood party back in September in her Hervé Légér dress, while the new mom toughens hers up with a leather jacket while hosting a party in Las Vegas this week. 20 of 43 LEIGHTON VS. KIM ST/Splash News; Dimitrios Kambouris/WireImage The Gossip Girl hit the N.Y.C. party scene in her Versace dress back in March, while the Lipstick Jungle actress later paired her blue jersey dress with gladiator sandals for the Entertainment Weekly upfronts party in N.Y.C. 21 of 43 VICTORIA VS. FERGIE Dexter Troy / Splash News; James Devaney/WireImage Posh headed out for a fashionable day in L.A. in her Dolce & Gabbana sheath, while the singer hit Cartier in Manhattan in her curve-hugging purple dress. 22 of 43 MANDY VS. RUMER Clark Samuels/Startraks(2) The singer gives new meaning to “pop princess” in her vintage Coca-Cola T-shirt while shopping in L.A., while the budding actress shows off the same shirt on the streets of New York City the very next day. 23 of 43 JENNIFER VS. KATHY EPA; Francis Specker /Landov It’s a fashion time warp, with the actress in a black and white Couture Couture dress at a press conference in Tokyo. Fast forward nine months to find comedian Kathy Griffin wearing the same look for a late-night TV appearance. 24 of 43 NICKY VS. SOLANGE Perez/Abbot/INF; London Entertainment/Splash News The heiress adds an edge to her star-printed Lacey Parker dress with a black biker jacket in N.Y.C., while Beyoncé’s younger sis keeps it cute with bright gladiator sandals and a low-slung belt at the Coachella music festival one month later. 25 of 43 ASHLEE VS. SELITA Peter Kramer/AP; Astrid Stawiarz/Getty The newly engaged singer hit a N.Y.C. party in her 3.1 Phillip Lim dress, while the Victoria’s Secret model attended the Tribeca Film Festival in her backless black one a week later. 26 of 43 JESSICA VS. TORI Kevin Mazur/WireImage; London Entertainment/Splash News Maternity battle! Alba was radiant in her Corey Lynn Calter maxidress at the Kids’ Choice Awards in L.A. in March, while Spelling headed out of a hair appointment in her green sundress this week. 27 of 43 DENISE VS. LEIGHTON Albert Ferreira/Startraks; Clark Samuels/Startraks The new reality star picked up her Armani Exchange dress at the line’s L.A. store, while the Gossip Girl snagged her wave-print dress at the New York boutique. 28 of 43 JENNA VS. EMMY Juan Rico/Fame; Andrew H. Walker/Getty The former porn star went for elegance in her yellow Dior gown at a L.A. premiere, while the actress was demure in her crystal-belted gown at a New York City benefit the next day. 29 of 43 LAUREN VS. ANNE Fame; Humberto Carreno/Startraks The Hills star topped off a spring outfit with her Marc by Marc Jacobs cardigan in L.A., while the Bride Wars actress kept warm in her two-tone sweater on the film’s Boston set. 30 of 43 AMY VS. RENéE Michael Caulfield/WireImage; Daniele Venturelli/WireImage The Enchanted actress took to the Academy Awards stage in her L’Wren Scott dress to perform “Happy Working Song,” while the Leatherheads star just worked it in her embroidered black dress at the film’s Rome premiere. 31 of 43 EVA VS. JEWEL Laborda/Enfoque/jpi; Kevin Mazur/WireImage The actress wore her Gustavo Cadile dress to a charity function last summer, while the singer wore her all-white lace dress to the CMT Awards this week. 32 of 43 MOLLY VS. GARCELLE Jamie McCarthy/WireImage; Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic The Vegas star showed off her Diane Von Furstenberg gown at a dinner party for the designer, while the new mom highlighted her post-baby body in her floral dress at a L.A. charity event. 33 of 43 CAMERON VS. AUDRINA Gaz Shirley/Pacific Coast News; James Breeden/Pacific Coast News The actress stepped out for errands in her J & Company jeans on Easter Sunday, while The Hills costar hit the streets of L.A. in her turquoise skinnies a few weeks later. 34 of 43 KATHERINE VS. KYLIE Octavio R Vera Jr / Splash News; Pacific Coast News The actress bundled up in her Juicy Couture sweater coat in L.A., while the singer headed out of her London home in her ivory knit jacket. 35 of 43 SOPHIA VS. KELLY Dave Allocca/Startraks; Jean-Paul Aussenard/WireImage The One Tree Hill star wore her Ports 1961 dress to a Fashion Week dinner, while Mrs. Travolta paired hers with black tights for The Memory Keeper’s Daughter premiere in L.A. last week. 36 of 43 MINKA VS. DANA Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic(2) The Friday Night Lights star flaunted her flirty Alice + Olivia dress at an event in Los Angeles, while the Prom Night actress hit the film’s L.A. premiere in her floral frock. 37 of 43 PARIS VS. GWEN DPA/Landov; Cousart-Ramirez-Rios/ JFX Same dress, same day, different continents! The heiress hit the German talk shows in her Diane Von Furstenberg dress, while the expectant mom headed to a pal’s L.A. baby shower in her patchwork maxidress. 38 of 43 HAYDEN VS. KRISTIN Shirley Buhl/Pacific Coast News; Clark Samuels/Startraks The Heroes actress wore her Gypsy 05 hoodie to the grocery store last month, while the reality star put on her eco-friendy sweatshirt to run errands in L.A. 39 of 43 LINDSAY VS. HEIDI Michael Caulfield/WireImage; Chris Polk/WireImage The actress partied in the Bahamas in her LaRok dress last summer, while the reality star attended a L.A. bash in her hot pink version in March. 40 of 43 DIANE VS. CELINE Kevin Mazur/WireImage; Jun Sato/WireImage The actress showed off her legs in her Balmain mini at the Movies Rock event in L.A. in December, while the emotive singer took the stage for her concert tour in her embellished black dress. 41 of 43 MARY VS. VIVICA Fitzroy Barrett /Landov; Marc Susset-Lacroix/WireImage The singer dazzled in her Emanuel Ungaro dress at the American Music Awards in November, while the actress lit up a French fashion party in February in her one-sleeve dress. 42 of 43 ASHLEY VS. MARY-KATE Dennis Van Tine/LFI; Stephen Lovekin/Getty Ashley sported her Calvin Klein jumpsuit to the designer’s show back in 2005, while her twin wore satin shorts to an after party for 21 in New York this week. 43 of 43 VANESSA VS. KOURTNEY VS. ADRIAN INF; Adrian Varnedoe/Pacific Coast News The High School Musical star hit the 11th Annual Best Buddies gala in Miami in her Sass & Bide dress in December, while the reality star and Cheetah Girl matched their striped dresses for a night on the town in Los Angeles recently.