Fashion Faceoff

Sometimes, stylish star minds think alike. You decide: Who wears it better? Vote on Hayden vs. Sienna and more. By Melissa Liebling-Goldberg

01 of 29

HAYDEN VS. SIENNA

HAYDEN VS. SIENNA
Brian Ach/WireImage; Goff/INF

The Heroes star celebrated her 18th birthday by visiting The Late Show in her Alice + Olivia dress, while the British actress sparkles in her sequined minidress at a London club opening.

Buy It!
Alice + Olivia Sequin Strap Dress, $440 at shopbop.com

02 of 29

PADMA VS. CARMEN

Image
Steve Buckley/BuzzFoto; Johns PkI / Splash News online

The Top Chef host celebrated at a pre-Emmys party in her white Marc Jacobs dress, while the actress showed off her tiered black dress at the designer’s N.Y.C. fashion show.

03 of 29

HEATHER VS. EMILY

Image
Michael Buckner/Getty; Jordan Strauss/WireImage

The Adrift in Manhattan actress played up her curves in her Michelle Jonas dress at a L.A. screening last November, while the Bones star sizzled in her clinging maroon number at a Hot in Hollywood event late this summer.

Buy It!
Michelle Jonas Short Keyhole Dress, $225 at michellejonas.com

04 of 29

LILY VS. KATE

Image
EMPICS /Landov; Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage

The British singer dazzles in her Chanel dress at the GQ Men of the Year Awards in London, while the actress is picture-perfect in her black and white frock at the recent Chanel event in Los Angeles.

05 of 29

ASHLEY VS. AUDRINA

ASHLEY VS. AUDRINA
Gregg DeGuire/WireImage; Jason Merritt/FilmMagic

The High School Musical 2 star worked her LaRok minidress at a Los Angeles event in April, while the Hills costar was stylish in her little black dress at the Teen Choice Awards a few months later.

Buy It!
LaRok “Wendy” dress, $248 at thehipchick.com

06 of 29

LEVEN VS. MYA

Image
inf; Jemal Countess/WireImage

The All My Children actress paid tribute to the Manhattan skyline in her Heatherette dress backstage at their February fashion show, while the singer showed off hers at the line s recent September show!

07 of 29

KATE VS. CHARLIZE

KATE VS. CHARLIZE
Paul McConnell/Getty; David Fisher / Rex

The Girl in the Park actress paired her lace Collette Dinnigan dress with a traditional headpiece for Australian Derby Day, while the In the Valley of Elah star was a bright spot in her white frock at the Venice Film Festival.

08 of 29

BIJOU VS. CARMEN

BIJOU VS. CARMEN
Richie Buxo / Splash News online; Astrid Stawiarz/Getty

It was a real-life faceoff when both actresses turned up at the Jill Stuart fashion show in N.Y.C. in the same purple minidress from the designer!

09 of 29

RIHANNA VS. KIMBERLY

Image
Kevin Mazur/WireImage; WENN

The sexy singer sizzled in her Gucci dress at the Kids Choice Awards, while the soon-to-be reality tv star got into the pattern mix with her printed mini while out to dinner in L.A.

10 of 29

KATE VS. THANDIE

KATE VS. THANDIE
Evan Agostini/Getty; Mike Cassese/reuters/landov

Same dress, same festival – in 24 hours! The Girl in the Park star showed off her hot pink Preen dress at the film’s premiere in Toronto on Sunday, while the Run, Fat Boy, Run actress worked her pocketed frock at her own film screening the next night.

11 of 29

HILARY VS. EMILY

HILARY VS. EMILY
Charles Sykes / Rex; Vince Flores/celebrity photo

The singer rocked her Vivienne Westwood gown at the GLAAD Media Awards in N.Y.C. back in March, while the CSI: Miami star worked her plunging dress at the Fashion Rocks event in N.Y.C. last week.

12 of 29

LAUREN VS. RACHAEL

Image
Donato Sardella/WireImage; Malcolm Taylor/Getty

The Hills star tried on her French Connection dress at the brand’s beach house in Malibu a week before the actress wore her cobalt blue number to the Toronto premiere of In the Valley of Elah.

13 of 29

HAYDEN VS. VANESSA

Image
Brian Ach/WireImage; Titomedia.com / Splash News online

The Heroes star hit the Late Show on her 18th birthday in her Alice + Olivia dress, while the High School Musical 2 actress dazzled at the film’s Australian premiere in her sequined minidress.

Buy It!
Alice + Olivia Sequin Strip Dress, $440 at thehipchick.com

14 of 29

STAR VS. CARMEN

Image
Ray Filmano / WENN; Gregorio Binuya/ABACA

The Court TV host showed off her Diane von Furstenberg dress while appearing on Live With Regis & Kelly, while the sexy star wore her two-tone dress to an N.Y.C. Fashion Week event.

Buy It!
Diane Von Furstenberg Contrast Tank Dress, $365 at neimanmarcus.com

15 of 29

SIENNA VS. JEMIMA

SIENNA VS. JEMIMA
DAVID LONGENDYKE/GLOBE; BIG PICTURES/BAUER-GRIFFIN

The actress was a vision in her white-and-gold Chanel dress at the Critic’s Choice Awards in January, while Hugh Grant’s main squeeze showcased her long legs in her minidress at a London charity event this week.

16 of 29

LILY VS. CAMERON

Image
Simon Seed/WireImage; Bill Davila/startraks

The British singer hit the V-Festival in her McQ-Alexander McQueen dress over jeans only a few days before the actress rehearsed in Manhattan for her new film What Happens in Vegas … in her billowing gray dress.

17 of 29

ASHLEY VS. KELLY

Image
Gregg DeGuire/WireImage; Fitzroy Barrett/Landov

The High School Musical 2 star hit the film’s L.A. premiere in her white BCBG dress, while the rocker turned chic in her buttoned white dress at the Teen Choice Awards.

18 of 29

SOPHIA VS. CARIDEE

SOPHIA VS. CARIDEE
Kevin Mazur/WireImage; George Napolitano/FilmMagic

The One Tree Hill star brightened up a VS Beauty Secret Garden Re-Launch in the Hamptons in her BCBG dress, while the America’s Next Top Model winner was sunny in her yellow frock at a charity event in N.Y.C. only four days later!

19 of 29

AMANDA VS. GWYNETH

AMANDA VS. GWYNETH
David Livingston/Getty; Tasos Katopodis/Getty

The new mom stepped out in her Marc Jacobs taffeta dress at an NBC party in July 2006, while the actress promoted a new Estee Lauder fragrance in her off-the-shoulder frock last week in Chicago.

20 of 29

ERIN VS. MICHELLE

Image
Marsaili McGrath/Getty; Steve Granitz/WireImage

The supermodel strutted her stuff in a feathered YSL dress at a party for the line in Los Angeles back in June, while The Heartbreak Kidactress joined the fashion flock in her little black dress at the film’s Los Angeles premiere last week.

21 of 29

JENNY VS. PARIS

Image
SS/Flynet; Chris Weeks/WireImage

The recent PEOPLE cover subject took her son out for some shopping in her Ella Moss minidress in L.A., while the heiress wore her striped dress to her sister Nicky’s birthday poker tournament in Las Vegas a few weeks later.

Buy It!
Ella Moss Coney Island Stripe Dress, $134 at revolveclothing.com

22 of 29

MISCHA VS. JENNIFER

MISCHA VS. JENNIFER
Richard Young/startraks; John P. Filo /Lando

The actress wore her gold-adorned Temperley London dress to the Soho House, while the tight-lipped star donned her loose green version for a visit to The Late Show this week.

Buy It!
Temperley London “Mini Pegasus” Dress, $2450 at net-a-porter.com

23 of 29

LIV VS. EVA

Image
Olivier Douliery/ABACA; Brian Ach/WireImage

The Reign Over Me actress put a new spin on the little black dress in her Zac Posen at the Toronto Film Festival, while the We Own The Night star sizzled in her backless dress at The Late Show in N.Y.C. this week.

Buy It!
Zac Posen Runway Tweed-Printed Delos Dress, $2100 at eluxury.com

24 of 29

ALYSON VS. JESSICA

Image
PRJ/Fame; Demis Maryannakis / Splash News online

The How I Met Your Mother star perked up a coffee outing in her Jenny Han shirtdress and knee-high boots, while the same night, the singer took a more revealing approach to her silk dress while clubbing in N.Y.C.

Buy It!
Jenny Han Shirt Dress, $160 at shopintuition.com

25 of 29

CARMEN VS. JAMIE-LYNN

CARMEN VS. JAMIE-LYNN
Gregorio Binuya/ABACA; Michael Simon/startraks

Electra hit N.Y.C Fashion Week in her two-tone Diane von Furstenberg dress, while The Gathering actress brightened up a morning talk show in her turquoise and black frock a few weeks later.

Buy It!
Diane von Furstenberg “Rosario” dress, $365 at dvf.com

26 of 29

SIENNA VS. KATIE

SIENNA VS. KATIE
EMPICS /Landov; Most Wanted/Flynet; St. Clair/Hammond/Splash News

THE Factory Girl actress dazzled in her Balenciaga babydoll at the film’s London premiere in March, while the Mad Money star looked chic in her sequined mini while boarding a flight in Berlin this week.

27 of 29

PARIS VS. DAISY VS. BROOKE

PARIS VS. DAISY VS. BROOKE
CURTIS/STARTRACKS; BARRETT /LANDOV; ANTHONY/PACIFIC COAST NEWS

Hilton first rocked the Black Halo dress this summer for a night out, while this week Fuentes looked sleek in hers at the Padres Contra El Cancer event in Los Angeles and Shields was chic in hers at a Coach dinner in N.Y.C.

Buy It!
Black Halo One Shoulder “Jackie” dress, $313 at shopintuition.com

28 of 29

CAMERON VS. PINK

CAMERON VS. PINK
SPLASH NEWS ONLINE; LIMELIGHT PICTURES

The actress showed off her famous legs in her Zac Posen minidress at a photocall for Shrek the Third in Berlin last June, while the singer hit a L.A. pumpkin patch in her flirty frock this week.

29 of 29

HAYDEN VS. JESSICA

HAYDEN VS. JESSICA
Humberto Carreno/startraks; Francis Specker /Landov

The Heroes star hit the streets of Manhattan in her What Comes Around Goes Around minidress back in September, while the singer dazzled in her sequined minidress at a Clothes Off Our Backs event in Los Angeles this week.

Buy It!
What Comes Around Goes Around “Anita” dress, $450 at shopbop.com

Related Articles