Lifestyle Style Can You Guess the 'Bachelor' Couple From the Engagement Ring? Spoiler: The size of the ring has nothing to do with how long the relationship lasts By Alex Apatoff Published on March 7, 2018 12:14 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Trending Videos 01 of 30 The Ring courtesy Neil Lane Details here 02 of 30 The Reveal ABC Hannah Ann and Peter 03 of 30 The Reveal ABC Details 04 of 30 The Reveal ABC Arie and Becca 05 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane Jeweler Neil Lane said this 3.5+-carat ring was a "wow ring" with "lots of personality," which the Bachelor picked out for the recipient from the beginning. 06 of 30 THE REVEAL One complication: He ended up proposing to a different girl with a different ring first. But after Arie Luyendyk, Jr. broke up with Becca Kufrin and decided to propose to runner-up Lauren Burnham on the After the Final Rose special, "he ended up picking the same one for Lauren that so intrigued him in the first place," Lane said. 07 of 30 THE RING Neil Lane The 3.75-carat round-cut diamond, set in a halo and flanked by two baguettes, was described by jeweler Neil Lane as "a classical look ... but also something modern and fashionable." 08 of 30 THE REVEAL Terhi Tuovinen/ABC Nick Viall chose this ring for Vanessa Grimaldi by trusting his gut: "I just closed my eyes and just envisioned her beautiful face. I knew immediately which one was perfect for her," he told PEOPLE. (They broke up five months later.) 09 of 30 THE RING Neil Lane The 4.25-carat Art Deco-style ring set with a central radiant-cut diamond and surrounded by over 240 round and baguette cut diamonds was the largest to have been given in the history of the franchise. 10 of 30 THE REVEAL The size wasn't the only thing extreme about it: In the middle of selecting it for Lauren Bushnell, "suddenly, without saying anything, [Ben Higgins] just stood up and left," jeweler Neil Lane tells PEOPLE. "It was very intense. That never happened before." Despite starring in a reality show about their courtship, the two couldn't make it last, and split in May 2017. 11 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane This 4-carat Neil Lane design was the show's biggest ever at the time, with an estimated value of $92,000. 12 of 30 THE REVEAL Nicole Kohl/ABC/Getty Chris Soules gave Whitney Bischoff this giant sparkler in season 19, but the ring – and the girl – weren't quite cut out for the farm, and the couple split six months later. 13 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane This 3.15-carat, $75,000 Neil Lane ring had extra sparkle thanks to the 164 pavé diamonds inset on a split-shank band. 14 of 30 THE REVEAL Dave Hagerman/ABC Sean Lowe delivered the jewelry to a very enthusiastic Catherine Giudici, who eventually also returned the favor with a Neil Lane band on their wedding day. 15 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane This 3-carat cushion-cut Neil Lane number had a romantic leaf pattern in the design. 16 of 30 THE REVEAL Nick Ray/ABC Lane hoped the nature motifs in Ben Flajnik's $50,000 ring for Courtney Robertson would help their love "bloom," but Robertson called things off and returned it to the show after about six months. 17 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane Lots and lots of bling accented this $50,000, 3-carat Neil Lane ring, which was chosen so that "no matter how she bent her finger, there would be sparkles everywhere you looked," Lane says. 18 of 30 THE REVEAL Mark Wessels/ABC Brad Womack gave Emily Maynard the glittery gem, but it was "no fairytale" – the couple called it off, a decision that Brad says was "completely my fault." 19 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane The Bachelor who picked this 2.72-carat princess-cut ring also had the honor of being dubbed "the most indecisive" about the choice by Lane. 20 of 30 THE REVEAL Mark Brendel/ABC Perhaps that indecision reflected an inability to commit: Jake Pavelka and Vienna Girardi parted ways three months after he placed this custom ring (which was reportedly returned to the show) on her finger. 21 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Neil Lane This Bachelor proposed with a 3.18-carat ring with a unique sideways-set Marquise diamond. 22 of 30 THE REVEAL Not only did Jason Mesnick and Melissa Rycroft not make it, he dumped her (while she was wearing the ring!) on the After the Final Rose special. (His new bride, the season's runner-up Molly Malaney, got her own Neil Lane ring years later.) 23 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Tacori This 3.5-carat Tacori stunner packs a punch – quite literally, the Bachelor found out. 24 of 30 THE REVEAL Craig Sjodin/ABC Mary Delgado reportedly was wearing the ring when she walloped fiancé Byron Velvick after a dispute about a Bachelor TV special. The two did not stay together. 25 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Chopard This Chopard solitaire was 2+ carats and conflict-free (not to mention noticeably less ornate than many of the other rings distributed on the show). 26 of 30 THE REVEAL Craig Sjodin/ABC/getty Andrew Baldwin and Tessa Horst got the Officer and a Gentleman sendoff – but not the happy ending: The two called it quits after a few months. 27 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Tacori This 2.85-carat Tacori sparkler had some of the more ornate scrollwork and diamond settings ever given on the show. 28 of 30 THE REVEAL Adam Larkey/ABC All that bling may explain why Shayne Lamas wanted to keep the ring from her ex, Matt Grant, "in a glass box like a glass slipper." Matt was not into that. 29 of 30 THE RING Courtesy Tacori This 1.2-carat promise ring from Tacori is set in a three-stone style traditionally meant to symbolize past, present and future. 30 of 30 THE REVEAL Craig Sjodin/ABC/Getty Unfortunately, Charlie O'Connell and Sarah Brice's future ended up being shorter than their past and present, and when they split, she put the ring on eBay.