Die-hard Cubs fan Karen Michel got the surprise of a lifetime when at Tuesday's World Series game, actor Bill Murray gifted her with a Game 6 ticket — right next to him!

No ticket? No problem!

Lifelong Cubs fan Karen Michel got the surprise of a lifetime at Tuesday’s World Series game when actor Bill Murray handed her a Game 6 ticket for the seat next to him – and she says they “really hit it off.”

“He kept offering me nachos and drinks,” Michel, 54, tells PEOPLE. “It was the funniest thing we were chattin’ like old friends!”

She says the actor noticed her walking away from the box office before the game, heartbroken, after she was unable to score last minute tickets to the game.

“I thought some people holding tickets might not show up or something, I figured I’d give it a shot but I wasn’t expecting much,” Michel, 54, tells PEOPLE. “It was crazy, Bill walked right by me, grabbed me and gave me a ticket! I said, ‘Where are we going?’ and he said, ‘You can come sit with me!’ ”

Murray escorted Michel to their seats — six rows behind home plate — and the two shared nachos while gabbing about Cubs players and cheering their team on.

World Series - Chicago Cubs v Cleveland Indians - Game Six
Jason Miller/Getty
| Credit: Jason Miller/Getty

The new friends were surrounded by celebrities, including Eddie Vedder of Pearl Jam (he sat a few rows in front of Murray and Michel) and Al Roker (in the row behind), at the game.

“We talked about growing up as Cubs fans and playing baseball,” says Michel, who was born and raised near Munster, Indiana. “Bill said he was born in Evanston and used to go to the games with his brother and he played catcher growing up.”

“He’s just so personable and we had a blast! We are both very knowledgable about baseball,” she adds.

When the game ended with a “beautiful” Cubs 9-3 win against the Cleveland Indians, Michel says she gave her new friend Bill Murray a great big hug.

RELATED VIDEO: Fans React To Chicago Cubs Making History with First World Series Win Since 1908

“I was so appreciative of what he did for me, he’s a solid guy,” she says. “I’ll always remember, because it was a once in a lifetime opportunity and it happened to me.”

Michel also invited the actor to the opening of the Mascot Hall of Fame near her home in Whiting, Indiana, next year.

“It seemed like something that he would love!” says Michel. “I’ve been a Cubs fan since I was 6 and he picked me out of a crowd to make my dream come true, it would be the least I could do to invite him to Whiting.”