Lifestyle Pets Woman Reunites with Missing Cat After Spotting Him on Shelter's Facebook Page Jimmy the missing cat arrived at a New Jersey shelter as a stray By Kelli Bender Kelli Bender Kelli Bender is the Pets Editor for PEOPLE Digital and PEOPLE magazine. She has been with the PEOPLE brand for more than eight years, working as a writer/producer across PEOPLE's Lifestyle, Features, and Entertainment verticals before taking on her current role. Kelli is also an editor on PEOPLE's Stories to Make You Smile and serves as an editorial lead on PEOPLE's World's Cutest Rescue Dog Contest and Pet Product Awards. Before joining PEOPLE, Kelli helped AOL and Whalerock launch a pet lifestyle site called PawNation. She is a pet parent to a cat named Wallace, and her professional and personal devotion to animals has taken her to three dog weddings ... so far. People Editorial Guidelines Published on April 12, 2017 04:35 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Photo: West Milford Animal Shelter Society Facebook: reuniting you with odd high school acquaintances, and now, missing cats. According to The Dodo, Sue Zelitsky recently reunited with her cat Jimmy, who had been missing for two years, thanks to a random Facebook post. On Sept. 12, 2014, Jimmy, an adventurous and friendly outdoor cat, was let outside for a little playtime, but he never came home. Usually when the 13-year-old cat was called he’d trot back to the door, but that night Jimmy didn’t respond to any of his owner’s increasingly desperate cries. After searching for the cat, Zelitsky put up fliers around her neighborhood asking others to keep an eye out for Jimmy. Months later, with no sign of her beloved pet, she began to accept he was never coming home. Thankfully, she was wrong. Two and half years after his disappearance, Sue Zelitsky was browsing her Facebook feed and spotted a posting about a stray recently pulled off the streets by West Milford Animal Shelter. This stray looked just like Jimmy. After a brief exchange with the shelter it seemed more and more likely that this feline was the same one she had spent so many years with. “He was found approximately 10 miles from our home after the big March blizzard and brought in to the West Milford Animal Shelter,” Zelitsky told The Dodo. “After some sharing of pictures and other physical attributes, I went to see him.” Not wanting to waste another moment wondering, Zelitsky gathered a few of Jimmy’s favorite things from around the house and went to the shelter with a neighbor who was a favorite of Jimmy’s. The New Jersey-based shelter, which is 100% volunteer run, was eager to invite them back to meet the stray, who everyone hoped was Jimmy. It took only a moment for Zelitsky to recognize her favorite feline face, and he seemed to know her too. “As soon as we opened the cage I asked him, ‘Jim, is that you bud?’ And he walked over and head-butted me and I just starting crying,” Zelitsky said. Jimmy is now back home with his family, catching up on lost time. Even the family dog recognized his old friend, and welcomed him back with open paws. Now 15 years old, Jimmy seems happy to be spending his golden years with the people (and pup) who love him the most.