"My maternal instinct is telling me it's a girl. We'll see if I'm right!" Renee Paquette tells PEOPLE of her baby on the way
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Renee Paquette pregnancy
Credit: Gaby Duong

Renee Paquette is going to be a mom!

The former WWE star, 35, and husband Jon Moxley are expecting their first child together, a rep for Paquette confirms to PEOPLE.

"We are so beyond excited to start this new chapter, and now finally having the world know feels like a weight has been lifted off my chest," says Paquette. "I am the worst at keeping fun secrets! However I definitely couldn't have predicted that the world would have found out on AEW Dynamite."

"I was thinking about all of these cute different ways that we could break the news to everyone and then bam, Jon just haphazardly spills the beans on Dynamite!" she adds of his Wednesday-night reveal. "But we're a kinda no-frills couple, so I guess it actually fit perfectly."

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Renee Paquette pregnancy
Credit: Gaby Duong

Paquette and Moxley, 34, "have a few names" in mind for their little one on the way "that we've been batting around the last few weeks, but we haven't hammered anything down yet."

"We don't even know if it's a boy or a girl yet, but we have options for both scenarios! My maternal instinct is telling me it's a girl. We'll see if I'm right!" Paquette tells PEOPLE. "Naming a person is crazy; it's a lot of pressure to get it right. But I think we'll probably lean towards something classic and timeless!"

The former Total Divas star tied the knot with professional wrestler Moxley in April 2017. To celebrate their three-year wedding anniversary this year, Paquette shared a snapshot of the couple riding horses together.

"Been married to this absolute hunk of a man for 3 years. I'm lucky. He's cute. 💕💕💕💕(one time we rode mules around some mountains)," she wrote in the caption.

RELATED VIDEO: WWE Star Maryse Mizanin Hilariously Reveals How Mike Sings to Get Daughter Monroe to Sleep

Aside from her journey to motherhood, Paquette is gearing up to launch her new podcast Oral Sessions, which premieres Tuesday and will star Moxley as her very first guest.

Moxley, meanwhile, will soon square off against Kenny Omega for the World Championship. The match is set to take place on Dec. 2.

AEW Dynamite airs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. ET on TNT.