The New York Yankees player, 35, and the former Astronaut Wives Club actress, 36, welcomed their second child, daughter Sailor Stevie Swisher, on Tuesday, June 28, their rep confirms to PEOPLE.
She weighed in at 7 lbs., 1 oz. and measured 18.5 inches long. Sailor joins big sister Emerson Jay, 3.
“So excited to introduce you to our tiniest princess, Sailor Stevie. She has stolen our hearts and our family feels complete,” the couple wrote on their respective Instagram accounts, sharing a photo of the proud parents holding their newborn baby girl.
Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.
“Watching Emme meet her baby sister for the first time was so incredible,” the couple tell PEOPLE exclusively. “We weren’t sure what to expect because she has been the center of our world, but she is so sweet and gentle with her. Our family finally feels complete. We can’t wait to see what’s in store for our precious little girls.”
“We are so excited that our family is growing and can’t wait to meet baby number two,” the couple told PEOPLE at the time, adding that Emme “keeps telling us she’s going to teach her little sister ‘everything she knows‘ … so we are counting on another expert on all things Princess Elsa, ponies and Play-Doh!”
“The best advice I have ever received is to trust your instincts and make sure to take care of yourself, too!” Garcia Swisher said in an interview for Eva Amurri Martino‘s lifestyle blog, Happily Eva After, in October.
“When I first had Emme, I was so focused on doing everything ‘right’ or ‘by the book’ that I forgot to listen to my gut and have confidence in that,” added Garcia Swisher, who has also played Ariel on Once Upon a Time.
— Jen Juneau with reporting by Sarah Michaud