Maya Erskine and Michael Angarano's romance first became Instagram official in September 2019
Michael Angaran
Credit: Michael Angaran/ instagram

Maya Erskine and Michael Angarano are engaged — and expecting!

The couple announced the happy news on Instagram Monday and shared photos of Erskine's baby bump. "When 2 becomes 3 😍👼 And please vote. #bidenharris2020," the PEN15 star, 33, captioned her photo.

"And then there were 3... also, we're engaged," actor Angarano, 32, wrote along with a photo of the parents-to-be cradling her baby bump.

Erskine and Angarano's romance first became Instagram official in September 2019.

Never miss a story -- sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories

At the time, he posted a selfie of them together at the Emmy Awards where they were both nominated.

"Ohhh look who it is sitting right behind me completely randomly at an awards show in which we were both nominated who I also happen to be in love with," wrote Angarano, who has starred in Sky High, Will & Grace and This Is Us.

Angarano, who previously dated Kristen Stewart and Juno Temple, was also featured in the latest season of Hulu's PEN15, which Erskine stars in with co-creator Anna Konkle.