Using two bottles filled with M&Ms, Danielle, 29, and Kevin, 28, challenged their followers to “make a guess” on the little girl’s gender. One bottle had a label reading “nuts” and the other, “no nuts” – a cute play on the type of candy and their baby’s sex.
In video from the gender reveal gathering, family members also guessed whether the newest addition would have “nuts” or “no nuts.”
“I knew it!” one excited guest declared after the news was revealed.
Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.
My Best Advice: Moms Share the Tips They Wish They Knew Before Kids
Danielle, who is due this winter, and Kevin’s daughter also posed with a giant balloon that said “Baby Girl” in an adorable photo montage.
“Alena is beyond thrilled to be a big sister and we can’t wait to meet the newest member of our family,” the soon-to-be parents of two previously told PEOPLE.
–– Lindsay Kimble