With the help of mom Heather Grabenstein, the sisters looked as cute as they did villainous. Landri wore a purple dress with puffy orange sleeves as Mary (Kathy Najimy), Alli dressed up in a pink-and-purple gown as Sarah (Sarah Jessica Parker) and Maddi wore a lookalike purple-and-green robe as Winifred (Bette Midler).
Each of the girls — who sported the witches’ signature hairstyles — added bold red lipstick, and Maddi even carried her own book of spells.
Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Parents newsletter.
“Oct. 1 rolls around and they’re asking, ‘Mommy, can we watch Hocus Pocus?’ ” Heather told Good Morning America. “They totally get into character, which is so funny.”
RELATED VIDEO: Happy Halloween! Here’s a Look at Our Three Favorite Onscreen Witches
Heather is already thinking ahead to Halloween 2019 but isn’t sure what she’s going to cook up. “But you can bet I’m going to figure out something,” she said.