November 13, 2011 08:00 PM

Barry Brecheisen/FilmMagic

As Twilight fans declare their loyalty for Team Edward or Team Jacob, Peter Facinelli can rest assured: the actor’s three daughters are all Team Carlisle.

“My [8½]-year-old daughter [Lola Ray] sleeps in Carlisle t-shirts, so that’s kind of cute,” Facinelli, 37, told PEOPLE on Tuesday during a Breaking Dawn event at the House of Blues in Chicago.

Facinelli, who portrays patriarch Dr. Carlisle Cullen in the Twilight films, reveals his daughters have all seen the first three movies and enjoy the franchise.

“My 14-year-old [Luca Bella] has read the first three books, she’s just reading the fourth one now,” he says.

And while his two eldest daughters have become fans, it’s 5-year-old Fiona Eve who gets “a little confused at times” between life on and off the screen.

“[Once] she wanted to go outside late at night, and I said, ‘We can’t go outside, there are coyotes,'” Facinelli recalls. “She goes, ‘Dad, that’s not real. That’s only in your movies.'”

No word on whether his wife of 10 years, former 90210 star Jennie Garth, is Team Carlisle as well.

— Nadine Shabeeb

You May Like