Superstore star Ben Feldman and his wife of four years, Michelle Mulitz, are first-time parents

F:PHOTOMediaFactory ActionsRequests DropBox48142#FeldmanCharlie-0003.jpg
Credit: Melinda Roth Photography

Ben Feldman is a dad!

The Superstore star’s wife Michelle Mulitz gave birth to a baby boy at 6:28 p.m. on Tuesday, Oct. 24, in Los Angeles, his rep confirms to PEOPLE exclusively.

“Charlie Milton Feldman was born on the Dodgers’ second home run in the series. He loves sleeping all day and partying all night,” the proud new parents joke to PEOPLE of their newborn son, who arrived weighing 6 lbs. and measuring 19 inches.

Of their son’s name, Feldman explains, “Milton was Michelle’s grandfather and Charlie is a f—ing adorable name!”

Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.

F:PHOTOMediaFactory ActionsRequests DropBox48142#FeldmanCharlie-0004.jpg
Charlie Milton Feldman
| Credit: Melinda Roth Photography
Charlie, Michelle Mulitz and Ben Feldman
| Credit: Courtesy Ben Feldman

The actor’s rep confirmed exclusively to PEOPLE in June that Feldman, 37, and Mulitz, 33 — who tied the knot in October 2013 at the Smokey Glen Farm in Gaithersburg, Maryland — would be welcoming a new addition into their household.

“I’m insanely lucky to have a wife with enough intelligence, compassion and responsibility to make it look like I know what I am doing here,” Feldman told PEOPLE.

FROM PEN: Milo Ventimiglia Explains Why He Decided to Be Less Public with His Personal Life

Mulitz debuted her baby bump at the 16th Annual Chrysalis Butterfly Ball in Brentwood, California, in June, wearing an orange off-the-shoulder dress while posing on the red carpet with her actor husband.

Apart from his roles on Superstore and Mad Men, Feldman has appeared on The Mindy Project, Drop Dead Diva and Silicon Valley. His film projects include the thrillers As Above, So Below and Cloverfield.

Charlie is the first child for both.

  • Reporting by SARAH MICHAUD