John Travolta appeared to hand Taylor Swift's "moon person" trophy to Jade Jolie on Monday night

Taylor Swift has one of the most recognizable faces on the planet, but that didn’t seem to stop John Travolta from apparently confusing her with one of her drag queen pals.

The Grease star, 65, sent Twitter into a tizzy when he appeared to mistake drag queen Jade Jolie for the “You Need To Calm Down” singer while handing over the award for video of the year.

Swift, 29, snagged the trophy for her “You Need to Calm Down” video, which featured Jade and other LGBTQ stars, many of whom Swift brought on stage to accept her win.

It’s unclear just what was going through Travolta’s head, but a brief moment that has since gone viral on Twitter shows the actor hold the trophy out to Jade Jolie as if to offer it to her.

Jade, wearing a pink outfit and a blonde wig similar to Swift’s hairstyle, smiles and laughs as Travolta extends an arm and pats her on the shoulder.

John Travolta and Jade Jolie
Credit: MTV

Travolta seemed to know a mistake was coming, as he jokingly asked his co-presenter Queen Latifah to read the Video of the Year winner’s name for fear he’d “f- it up.”

Check out PEOPLE’s full MTV VMAs coverage to get the latest news on one of music’s biggest nights.

It’s not Travolta’s first awards show flub — at the 2014 Oscars, he infamously mispronounced Idina Menzel’s name as “Adele Dazeem” while presenting her with the Oscar for Best Original Song.

Jolie, meanwhile, smiled for a video backstage with Swift, where the two basked in their win.

RELATED VIDEO: Taylor Swift Lip-Syncs to ‘You Need to Calm Down’ at Party to Celebrate Her 10 VMA Nominations

“So we are backstage, not really able to process…what did just happen?” Swift asks, to which the RuPaul’s Drag Race alum replies, “Um, you won video of the year!”

In response, Swift credits her win to everyone, saying, “We, it’s a collective…”

The 2019 MTV Video Music Awards are airing live from Newark, New Jersey’s Prudential Center on Monday, Aug. 26, at 8 p.m. ET.