Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin currently have their sights set on a tropical wedding ceremony, a source tells PEOPLE

Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin want to make sure their wedding ceremony is one for the history books!

The couple, who secretly exchanged vows at a civil courthouse ceremony in September, are still finalizing the details for a religious ceremony and reception — and they currently have their sights set on a destination wedding!

“Justin and Hailey both love tropical destinations. They are currently looking into options for a tropical wedding,” a Bieber source tells PEOPLE.

Although it initially looked like the couple were eyeing a winter bash, “it seems it will happen in April, or May instead,” the source shares.

Hailey Baldwin and Justin Bieber
| Credit: Kahlea Baldwin/Instagram

“Although they are already married, they both want their wedding to be perfect,” the insider adds. “Hailey is working closely with their planner and figuring everything out. She is very excited to plan her wedding.”

While there are many locales around the world the happy couple could choose, the pop star, 24, may have his sights set on one tropical location, which has already gotten the seal of approval from one of the couple’s pals.

Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin Seen Taking A Break Whilst In London At Joe In The Juice
Credit: Splash News

As Kylie Jenner posted dozens of photos documenting her recent trip with daughter Stormi, BFF Jordyn Woods and boyfriend and Stormi’s father, Travis Scott, Bieber hinted that he would have appreciated an invite.

In one Instagram post, which featured palm trees and sparkling blue water, Jenner wrote, “don’t ever wanna leave.”

“Wow lucky where’s the invite to hails and i,” Bieber wrote, to which Jenner replied, “lolll you love birds can come next time.”

A source previously told PEOPLE that while the couple are eager to celebrate their wedding with family and friends, “there’s no real rush.”

“They’re working with the schedules of all their friends and family to make sure they can be surrounded by the people they love,” the source added. “There’s no real rush. They’re already legally married, but they’re very excited about throwing a celebration with their loved ones.”

RELATED VIDEO: Hailey Baldwin Returns to Runway for First Time Since Marrying Justin Bieber

Even though the couple have yet to set a date, their family members can’t stop gushing over how well-suited the pair are for each other.

“They’re perfect for each other because they’re like the same person,” Hailey’s cousin Ireland Baldwin, 23, told PEOPLE earlier this month. “They’re both really sweet. They complement each other. They’re both every loving of each other.”

Ireland also explained that the young couple is also experiencing life at the same speed.

“They’re going through the same struggles, I feel like, and they are just helping each other out. As life goes, we all go,” Baldwin said of her cousin.

Bieber’s mother, Pattie Mallette, has also been singing the 22-year-old model’s praises.

Earlier this month, Mallette, 43, shared a sweet selfie of herself with Baldwin, captioning the image, “What a gift!”

“Love you,” Baldwin replied.