People.com Entertainment Music John Mayer Shares Sweet Tribute on Andy Cohen's 50th Birthday: 'You Are Such a Special Person' John Mayer ran into a little difficulty coming up with the perfect way to wish his BFF Andy Cohen happy birthday By Maria Pasquini Maria Pasquini Associate Editor, Human Interest - PEOPLE People Editorial Guidelines Published on June 3, 2018 05:05 PM Share Tweet Pin Email Sometimes finding the perfect words to let your friend know how much they mean to you is tough. Just ask John Mayer! After taking “about 30 minutes” to write the perfect caption to celebrate his BFF Andy Cohen‘s 50th birthday, Mayer was ready to admit defeat. “Happy 50th Birthday @bravoandy!” Mayer, 40, wrote alongside a dimly lit elevator selfie of the close pals. “It’s been about 30 minutes since I started writing this caption. Congratulations, I have no words. You’ve done it. Can’t find em right now. They’re all scattered in a flurry of love and memories OH HERE THEY COME.” After his jolt of inspiration, the “New Light” singer added, “I love you, and you are such a special person that I’m sure you are known throughout the universe. See you tonight 🎈 ♥” John Mayer’s ‘New Light’ Music Video Is a Green Screen Dream (and Just as Extra as He Is) Later in the day, Mayer booked it from his Dead and Company show in Camden, New Jersey, to New York City for Cohen’s birthday bash. “Made it just in time to give a hug to the birthday boy, strum a few songs, and take this photo with NASA-level filtering on it. 🍰,” the musician wrote of a photo booth snap of the buddies. John Mayer Takes Over WWHL for Andy Cohen’s 50th Birthday — and Jokes About Romance Rumors On Monday, Cohen shared his own appreciation for Mayer and his longtime close pal Bruce Bozzi, who threw Saturday evening’s fiesta. “My heart is bursting all over the place, due in no small part to these two special friends who went the extra mile to make sure I had the best birthday ever,” he captioned a photo of the trio. “Love you John & Brucie.” Watch the full season of Search History on PeopleTV.com or download the PeopleTV app on your favorite device. In Cohen’s own nod to his milestone birthday, the Watch What Happens Live host wrote “allegedly I’m 50 today” alongside a photo of himself walking his dog in the West Village neighborhood of New York City. He also shared a cheeky look at a birthday treat, confessing that he believed the confection’s topper bore a slight resemblance to male genitalia. “My Snoopy cake-topper looks like a d—!” the birthday boy wrote alongside an image of the cartoon creation. RELATED VIDEO: Andy Cohen Dishes on Met Gala Shenanigans — and Teases Which Star Was ‘the Drunkest’ After the special decoration got customized just for Cohen, the television host excitedly added, “Now it has my NAME on it!” Want to keep up with the latest from PEOPLE? Sign up for our daily newsletter to get our best stories of the day delivered straight to your inbox. Andy Cohen/Instagram Andy Cohen Celebrates Close Pal John Mayer’s 40th Birthday with ‘Magic’ Trip to Brazil: ‘My Heart Is Busting’ Cohen previously penned a warm birthday message to Mayer when the singer turned 40 in October 2017. The singer celebrated the happy occasion by bringing a group of friends — including Cohen and Bob Saget — to Brazil. “This right here is an ELECTRIC COWBOY! They only made one @johnmayer,” Cohen captioned a photo of the pair sitting side by side. “We are lucky to have him. Happy Birthday 💗⚡💗⚡. #JM40.” Cohen later shared a second tribute for the birthday boy, adding, “My heart is busting out with a whole lotta feels after an experience of a lifetime. Brazil is Magic and so are you, JM.” As an extra special birthday gift, this year Mayer surprised Cohen by taking over hosting duties on a birthday edition of Cohen’s Bravo show. The celebrations included cake, balloons, an embarrassing dive into Cohen’s vault of personal videos, a special serenade and a few jokes about the pair’s bromance. “Do you think people wonder if we’re in a secret relationship?” Mayer asked his pal. “All my team does,” Cohen retorted. Watch What Happens Live: Andy’s 50th Birthday aired Sunday at 10 p.m. ET on Bravo.